PDA

View Full Version : Too Similar To another Game


CLONECOMMANDER501
05-08-2007, 09:04 PM
I just want to point out even though I'm 80% retired from modding this game, I am not complaining about it.

I find this game too similar to Rome Total War. Like

. the good graphics theme

. you have to conquer planets, in RTW you have to conquer settlements

. RTW have Armies on the map aka fleets in EAW

.There can be trade between settlements, you need roads, which act like trade routs in EAW

.The Coding. TOO similar


. Diplomacy, the feature is avaliable through some easy modding in EAW


. The advisors on the known world map/ galactic map

. In RTW, your general gives a speech before a battle, just like the pilot/stormtrooper does

. Field commanders give morale like generals in RTW do


. Units can retreat and there is an auto resolve feature

.

L0rdReV@n88
05-08-2007, 10:14 PM
they are both real time strategy games if im not mistaken. i havent played RTW but most of these real time games all have very similar features except RTW and other are missing the best thing of all star war

Darth Anarch
05-09-2007, 05:41 PM
Not to mention that it's a lot like C&C3, because there are little units shooting at other little units. They should have just stopped making RTS games after Dune 2.

*Sarcasm meter explodes*

DarthMaulUK
05-10-2007, 09:07 AM
Don't you mean C&C3 is alot like this? Apart from lacking in 3d cameras of course. All RTS games are starting to have the same theme, which you have to expect once they removed micro management.

Besides, Empire at War is the only one here to combine both space and land battles.

DMUK

CLONECOMMANDER501
05-10-2007, 09:04 PM
Grrr... But notice the Empire at WAR and Rome Total WAR

DarthMaulUK
05-11-2007, 03:32 AM
Let me get this right....because a game has WAR in the title, its smiliar? Utter rubbish. Rome Total War and Empire at War are two totally different games.

RTW focuses more on mass battles and castle seiges and of course, uses out of date weaponary. Empire at War is space, more close combat, space battles. Just because both games use a map for campaigns doesnt make them the same.

If that was the case, you could say Dawn of War is a clone. RTS games follow along the same sort of formula and have for many years. All 3 of these games are good in their own right.

DMUK

wedge2211
05-11-2007, 11:29 PM
Being "similar" to another game (particularly in the weak sense that both games are of the same genre) isn't necessarily a BAD thing...

Darth Windu
05-12-2007, 01:31 AM
There is almost nothing in common between EaW and Rome: Total War. Rome is a far better developed and in-depth game than EaW is or will ever be. The way I see it, you could only say that EaW is a extremely simplified noob-style version of Rome without the diversity, politics, and strategy.

CLONECOMMANDER501
06-10-2007, 09:07 AM
There is democracy in EAW, its hidden in the game files but it's easy to bring back.

Darth_Extas
06-10-2007, 03:13 PM
By What I have seen, I think an even more recent game may be similar to this... Company of Heros has a possiblity...Although the graphics engine might be more refined...