PDA

View Full Version : The Rogue Jedi


Demyse
05-19-2002, 09:06 PM
Alright people, I just saw Episode II. My jaw is now in a permanant dropped position after seeing it. But I've got to thinking (Uh oh, this can be bad, very bad) that Anakin really really seems a bit like a Rogue Jedi in this movie. Now, after playing JK2 for about 12 times over (the last 1 on Jedi Master with realistic saber combat on, damn that was hard) and seeing the Rogue Jedi in there, I just had to make this poll. Who's the cooler Rogue Jedi, Kyle or Anakin.

Vestril
05-20-2002, 04:15 AM
He slaughtered a camp of Tuskens--even Kyle has a line. Anakin is far too much of a badass not to get my vote.

striderx2048
05-20-2002, 11:43 AM
there a different between being rogue, and ruthless
vader is ruthless not a rogue

Murdoch
05-20-2002, 11:58 AM
Sure but the question is who's the coolest.

Well, both Kyle and Vader has lot's of style and great voices. Great fighters, grip monkeys etc. But.. Vader has the armour and he's plain and simple evil. Vader takes it by a narrow margin.

Vestril
05-20-2002, 03:30 PM
This would probably just ruin the argument in favor of Kyle, but aren't we comparing Kyle to Anakin, not Kyle to Vader? Vader is a Dark Jedi, Anakin is more of a Rogue Jedi...

whitedragon
05-20-2002, 04:48 PM
kyle could probley take anakin. though i will say this before people start calling me a dumbass. kyle could take anakin not vader.vader would probley beat the **** out of kyle like dessan beating kyle without force power

Vestril
05-20-2002, 04:52 PM
Originally posted by whitedragon
kyle could probley take anakin. though i will say this before people start calling me a dumbass. kyle could take anakin not vader ok? ok!

Kyle--found his lightsaber in his dad's shed, and trained in the Force for three days

Versus

Anakin--who is tremendously strong in the Force and trained for years.

*thinks about it*

whitedragon
05-20-2002, 04:53 PM
Originally posted by Vestril


Kyle--found his lightsaber in his dad's shed, and trained in the Force for three days

Versus

Anakin--who is tremendously strong in the Force and trained for years.

*thinks about it*
i am but anakin dident go to the valley of the jedi did he

Vestril
05-20-2002, 04:59 PM
Kyle didn't use thew Valley of the Jedi to enhance his Force skills, he used to get them back faster. Kyle can't even sense people in the Force, he's too unskilled to tell when someone is walking up behind him (he asks Luke how he does it)--Anakin can sense when there are insects crawling around in the room next to him.

In Nar Shadda if you try to jump onto a moving speeder you get killed--in AotC Anakin jumps onto a moving speeder, he has no problem.

Divine Spirit
05-20-2002, 05:05 PM
Anakin and Kyle?? HAH! what have they ever done?

my vote is saved for Kyp Durron, he single handedly piloted a space ship that can blow apart whole SYSTEMS! and joy rided it around the galaxy blowing any imperial fleets into a billion pieces! he is SURELY the best rogue jedi there ever was and probably every will be!


Divine Spirit

Vestril
05-20-2002, 05:10 PM
Originally posted by Divine Spirit
Anakin and Kyle?? HAH! what have they ever done?

my vote is saved for Kyp Durron, he single handedly piloted a space ship that can blow apart whole SYSTEMS! and joy rided it around the galaxy blowing any imperial fleets into a billion pieces! he is SURELY the best rogue jedi there ever was and probably every will be!


Divine Spirit

*cries* Why did you have to bring him up....*curses Kevin J. Anderson once again*

Divine Spirit
05-20-2002, 05:18 PM
Originally posted by Vestril


*cries* Why did you have to bring him up....*curses Kevin J. Anderson once again*

haha, i was just saying! :D


Divine Spirit

Jedi_Monk
05-20-2002, 05:19 PM
my vote is saved for Kyp Durron, he single handedly piloted a space ship that can blow apart whole SYSTEMS! and joy rided it around the galaxy blowing any imperial fleets into a billion pieces! he is SURELY the best rogue jedi there ever was and probably every will be!
Any idiot with half a brain could've pilotted the Suncrusher... ech!

As for Anakin vs. Kyle... ponder this, will I :yoda:

Murdoch
05-20-2002, 05:25 PM
It would be wise to take Kyles manly beard into account...

Jedi_Monk
05-20-2002, 05:33 PM
But then, Anakin gets Padme as played by the beautiful Natalie Portman (bloody lucky sob!) while Kyle only gets Jan... hm... ::drops a checker in Anakin's side of the scale::

whitedragon
05-20-2002, 06:23 PM
Originally posted by Vestril

In Nar Shadda if you try to jump onto a moving speeder you get killed--in AotC Anakin jumps onto a moving speeder, he has no problem.
mabey because kyle isent really jumping is he. you are makeing him jump. if it was really him jumping he could probly jump on several in a row before getting to where he needed to go

whitedragon
05-20-2002, 06:26 PM
Originally posted by Divine Spirit
Anakin and Kyle?? HAH! what have they ever done?

my vote is saved for Kyp Durron, he single handedly piloted a space ship that can blow apart whole SYSTEMS! and joy rided it around the galaxy blowing any imperial fleets into a billion pieces! he is SURELY the best rogue jedi there ever was and probably every will be!


Divine Spirit
he blew them up because he had a indestructable wepon called the SUN CRUSHER and he became an apprentis to the sith lord whats his name (i dont know how to spell his name) he wasent that good of a jedi

Vestril
05-20-2002, 06:39 PM
mabey because kyle isent really jumping is he. you are makeing him jump. if it was really him jumping he could probly jump on several in a row before getting to where he needed to go

Huh :confused:

You do realize that Kyle is just a character in a game, don't you? He does not exist in real life, or even in the movies.

striderx2048
05-20-2002, 08:48 PM
Originally posted by Vestril


Huh :confused:

You do realize that Kyle is just a character in a game, don't you? He does not exist in real life, or even in the movies.

kyle is official recognize in the star wars character databanks

whitedragon
05-20-2002, 08:52 PM
Originally posted by Vestril


Huh :confused:

You do realize that Kyle is just a character in a game, don't you? He does not exist in real life, or even in the movies.
thats what i ment it just came out funney. if he was in a movie or a book thats what i ment. sorry it came out wrong:lol:

Chaotic~Angel
05-20-2002, 08:57 PM
I'd have to put my vote on Anakin. His flaring emotions make him an unpredictable fighter and he is born with a high strength in the force.

Kyle has (in these games) however conquered many dark jedi and tasted the dark side for himself BUT thats only because they made a game out of him :p

If a game was made about Anakin slaughtering bad guys and jedi/sith he would kick some major tooshie :)

Wamprat013
05-20-2002, 08:58 PM
Originally posted by Jedi_Monk
But then, Anakin gets Padme as played by the beautiful Natalie Portman (bloody lucky sob!) while Kyle only gets Jan... hm... ::drops a checker in Anakin's side of the scale::

yes, but...
Kyle gets my vote for 2 reasons:

1) anakin becomes an evil dark jedi with no connection to the light side, and he only wears the cool armor becuase he has some injury the won't let him live without it, and he dies, and padme must die in episode 3 b cuz i think thats what pusheds anikin over the edge

2) kyle has more power, he can use lightning, only the emporor, desann, kyle, and dookoo can do that, u ever seen vader do it?
and he has the ability to learn not only the sweet choke, lighting, and other offencive powers of the dark side, but becuase he is always welcome to the valley of the jedi (he saved it from jerec) he can develop all the sweet force powers that a ligth jedi can learn.

just your friendly neiborhood wamprat!
:fett: :jawa :ewok: :atat: :deathstar :deathii:

whitedragon
05-20-2002, 09:09 PM
just because it dident show vader useing the force lightening dosent mean he dident know how. but i guess he liked the force grip better (like me:p ) it would be cool if it showed vader lifting someone up and tossing them into a deep cavern. i like to do that especially to dark jedi. they are not as powerful as they think ha ha ha HA HA HA HA HAAAA..*cough cough cough* sorry i just thought of something funney..........

Chaotic~Angel
05-20-2002, 09:13 PM
What some of you do not realize is that Vader/Anakin is a movie character and Kyle is a game character. If Vader/Anakin could use lightning and all the light side moves he would have beaten up the emperor and assumed power. Also he would have healed his wounds. If Kyle on the other hand could only use light/dark abilities and only a certain few the game would flop. So the comparison is too hard to make

whitedragon
05-20-2002, 09:24 PM
Originally posted by Chaotic~Angel
What some of you do not realize is that Vader/Anakin is a movie character and Kyle is a game character. If Vader/Anakin could use lightning and all the light side moves he would have beaten up the emperor and assumed power. Also he would have healed his wounds. If Kyle on the other hand could only use light/dark abilities and only a certain few the game would flop. So the comparison is too hard to make
i know the difference and if everyone cared about that little detail then this thread wouldent exist. come on of corce vader could take kyle out but were talking about AotC anakin. vader is one of my faverot sith lords right up there with darth maul (ive read the book shadow hunter)

Vestril
05-20-2002, 10:11 PM
Originally posted by whitedragon

i know the difference and if everyone cared about that little detail then this thread wouldent exist. come on of corce vader could take kyle out but were talking about AotC anakin. vader is one of my faverot sith lords right up there with darth maul (ive read the book shadow hunter)

Could Obi Wan take on Kyle Katarn? AotC Obi Wan, I mean.

whitedragon
05-20-2002, 11:09 PM
Originally posted by Vestril


Could Obi Wan take on Kyle Katarn? AotC Obi Wan, I mean.
woah that is going to be a hard decision...yikes you sure do know how to start good arguments :rolleyess :D