PDA

View Full Version : Palpatine/sidious Dispute


ash_007
06-01-2002, 12:25 AM
Ok first things first I am NOT new to star wars, I am a die hard fan. But I think ive missed all the "hints" the them being the same person. Will someone please shed some light on this.

MUHAHAHAHAHA
06-01-2002, 12:58 AM
Die Hard fans should've known this since ROTJ, but here's a few clues that you might not have picked up on.

1) the lightning he uses vs. Luke.... only a Sith or (maybe) Jedi could use that

2) Emperor Palpatine is described many places, and it's quite obvious after Episode 2 that he is putting himself in position to take on that role.

3) the voice, the way he tells Anakin he forsees him becoming the most powerful of all the Jedi, the way he "persuades" people into voting for him to take on a higher and higher role in the Republic govt....

4) the chin - this one really gives it away, you can see his mouth and chin even with the cloak, and it's obvious that this is the same person as Palpatine.

5) starwars.com - yes, it's not canon, but it's the official website

Darkhold X
06-01-2002, 01:03 AM
I think its pretty damn aparent that they are one, and the same. I didnt know people had any questions as to who he was.

the whole dumb siious thing was just probably something to hide his identity until he was in position to take over all the way I guess.

BradFu
06-01-2002, 01:10 AM
In addition, it's clear that all the Sith lords take on a Darth name, and Sidious is simply Palpatine's Sith name. When he makes himself Emperor, he'll have no need to hide himself anymore, and will just use his real name.

The fact that Ian McDiarmiad plays both Palpatine and Sidious is enough proof that they are the same person. The only alternate for that could be that they're twins or clones, which is really reaching. There really shouldn't be any dispute. If it turns out to be a twist where they aren't the same person, then cool, it'll be a suprise. But until that actually happens, it's ridiculous to think they're different people.

BradFu!

ash_007
06-01-2002, 01:11 AM
i noticed the chin and all but i still dont understand, i honestly dont think they are the same person. But if so many ppl say that they are then i guess im wrong

Akshara
06-01-2002, 01:17 AM
Other Hints...

It's the same actor playing the Emperor in ROTJ and Palpatine in the new movies.

In the three novels by Timothy Zahn, which were the official Lucas release of his chapter 7-9 episodes, the Emperor is often referred to as Emperor Palpatine.

Cmdr. Antilles
06-01-2002, 01:42 AM
Well yeah, we all know that Palpatine is going to be the Emperor, but what they're debating is Palpatine Darth Sidious? I personally think he is.

Klorel
06-01-2002, 02:13 AM
maybe he is, maybe he isn't. the real question is... who IS anakins father? all that medachlorian bs isn't flying.... something isn't being told. maybe shmi was under a mind trick or something, who knows..... i feel that this is the twist in episode III. maybe i'm wrong, just speculating, throwing this out there. Is Sidious anakin's father? its possible.

Cmdr. Antilles
06-01-2002, 02:20 AM
Eww... Who would want to have kids w/ him? Eww... :D

Oh right, mind trick...

Epimetheus
06-01-2002, 02:21 AM
This really isn't the board for this. (Besides, I already managed to start this controversy in the Sidious/Palpatine model thread)

Klorel
06-01-2002, 03:08 AM
lol.... so you screwed up someone elses forum with the same question? the irony... anyhoo, he'd have to use the mind trick.... or would he! i mean, a single mom, raising a kid alone in this galaxy, and a swell guy like SENATOR palpatine strolls by. I mean, he is human, not a machine, senators need love too. she couldnt resist, but felt guilty cause she was slutty and decided to block the event from her mind and latter got amnesia anyways! hahaha. j/k

Oooh oooh, how about this [this is the biggest, sickest stretch ever, if you value rational thoughts, skip this and read the next post]:
Master YODA, triggers the medachlorians to impregnate shmi, and then secretly trains sidious knowing the whole time that if there is balance to the force, its gotta get bad before it gets good, and that is why yoda lives, he's the master mind, and when its all over and the galaxy is a dictatorship (all part of yoda's master plan) he hides in the swamp and no one is the wiser. and then happens to manifest obiwan to summons luke to see him. (did we see anyone talking to the dead before? no) thats right. all the ghosts are just manifestations created by yoda (who faked his own death with a mind trick) and tricks luke into confronting vader to once again bring balance to the force.... i apologize in advance :o

anyways, how could palpatine be sidious, i mean, palpatine is such a super keen guy and sidious is mean... he's not the hulk you know... they couldnt possibly be the same person. Maybe the senator is a robot like in Austin Powers II, and his maker: Sidious, takes his place. Man, i should write conspiracy theories.


SERIOUSLY THOUGH:
i am still torn on this issue. i want to believe lucas has a twist up his sleeve, but i guess we'll just have to wait and see.

oddjob: A-Team
06-01-2002, 04:18 AM
http://us.imdb.com/Name?McDiarmid,+Ian

It's the same actor. Of COURSE they are the same person. I am surpised there is any question at all.

ShodiKGian
06-01-2002, 11:11 PM
The main reason I realized that they were the same person were from cinematic clues, the best one is at the end of Episode I. Mace Windu says "But which did was killed the master or the apprentice?" And the camera zooms on Palpatine's profile. That action alone indicates that Palpatine is a Sith, and if there can indeed be only two, and Sidious said Maul was his apprentice, than Palpatine has to be Sidious.

There are other cinematic hints, but like I said that is the most obvious.

Darkhold X
06-01-2002, 11:39 PM
Everyone already knows that Palpatine is the emperor later on, so why in the world would people think sidious is someone else?

Ray Stantz
06-01-2002, 11:46 PM
Then you have the fact that Palpatine is basically wearing the same type of cloak in RotJ as Sidious is. If not the same one.

"Which did was killed" What are you on.

"But which was destroyed, the master or the apprentice?"

Darkhold X
06-02-2002, 12:21 AM
LOL I think the greatest thing if you look at the affiliation thing on Palpatine's page on the official site it says sith, and soon as you click it you see a pic of palpy, and maul.:D

"And despite the death of his prized apprentice, none of the Jedi knew for sure of Sidious' existence, or of his true identity."
Hmm I wonder what his true identity could be....?:D

seriously a brain dammaged monkey could figure it out, not that there is any mystery about it.

Epimetheus
06-02-2002, 12:21 AM
Actually, the first time I saw the shot of Palpatine at the end, I immedeately noticed Anakin behind his profile, thinking "Oh, there's the future master and his apprentice". And then we laughed and laughed and I got shot in heart.