View Full Version : How luke remembers Dagobah

08-05-2002, 11:32 PM
As you know, in The Empire Strikes Back, Luke says that Dagobah seems like familiar place. But how could he have been there if he was Tatooine with Obi-wan the whole time? Simple.

After the rise of the Empire, there were only 2 jedi left, Obi-wan and Yoda. Yoda flees to Dagobah and Obi-wan flees to Tatooine. Obi-wan is probably given Luke by Padme to be hidden by the emperor. The only way to explain how Luke sees that Dagobah is familiar to him is that Obi-wan goes to Dagobah first!

If you know, Yoda's last pupils were Obi-wan and Luke. It says so at the databank at www.starwars.com . Obi-wan must have taken Luke with him to Dagobah to train further with Yoda, then left with Luke for Tatooine and gave Luke to be taken care of his Uncle Owen.

That's how I think Dagobah is familiar to Luke.

08-06-2002, 12:04 AM
Interesting theory Arkum.
Also it could be that Luke saw it in a dream. Remember that Jedis can dream or forsee the future through meditation or dreams.

08-06-2002, 12:26 AM
o yeah, good point:p

Darth Damage
08-06-2002, 01:43 AM
arkum i would love to see dagobah in EP3 great theory

08-06-2002, 04:38 PM
Originally posted by boba fett c3po
no they werent yodas last pupils, what do you think all those little kids in ep 2 in the jedi temple were?

Those were some of his pupils, but Yoda's LAST 2 pupils were
Obi-wan and Luke, it says so at the databank at www.starwars.com Search for Yoda, it will say that his LAST 2 pupils were Luke and Obi-wan

ET Warrior
08-06-2002, 08:36 PM
but who would Yoda have trained between obiwan and luke? Not counting the kids in Bear Clan of course. I'm guessing that Yoda kind of takes obi-wan in under his wing after QuiGon dies, and helps him out. We know that he likes obiwan, as Dooku tell obiwan that Yoda holds him in such high regards.

As for luke finding Degobah familiar, it doesn't mean that he's ever been there before. He could have had a vision from the force, a dream, or it could just be one of those feelings you get even if you've never ever seen the place. But he COULD have gone to degobah............we will never ever know.......okay, we'll know after episode 3.........but not until then!!! ;)