View Full Version : Rating 1-10

11-13-1999, 12:45 AM
On a scale of 1-10 how would you rate the game?(Based on the demo, of course)

11-13-1999, 07:51 AM
I give it an 8/10. Reasons:

1. No mouselook. I know, I know, it's not designed for that, but Jedi Knight had this in third-person, and it was a great help for me, and would be here, too.

2. Collision detection. Indy seems to be fatter that he really is. He stops in front of walls when he still has about a quarter of a meter left to walk.

3. (This is really nit-picking) Jumping. Indy can't possibly jump as far as the long jump. Come on, he's not Kyle Katarn or Lara Croft! He's more like a Gordon Freeman: Jumping has to be true-to-life.

If ANY one of these were corrected in a future patch, The game would be perfect.

(In my opinion, of course http://www.indyjones.net/forums/biggrin.gif)

Kerm Vader
11-13-1999, 05:36 PM
I was very surprised by this demo. The atmosphere is great, the controls are much better than TR after you get used to them, and the gameplay is great. But the ATMOSPHERE! That is what truly sets this apart.

11-13-1999, 09:12 PM

"There's no need to fear, your local Grand Admiral is near!"

11-15-1999, 03:00 PM
I'd say a 9....

..yeah a 9.

11-15-1999, 03:56 PM
I'll give it a 8.5 and this is just the demo. When the full game arrives it should hit the top http://www.indyjones.net/forums/smile.gif


11-15-1999, 06:22 PM
I say 9.2. The graphics show their age.. but I truly love all of the other aspects of the game.

Ms. Talon
11-15-1999, 06:31 PM
2 out of 10.

I think this may be another "Phantom Menace" game; a mediocre and un-imaginative game, slow and clunky, but with a big name to sell to the mass-market--geared more to the non-gamer.

Hamster Idol
11-15-1999, 07:31 PM
8.5 This didn't impress me the way Fate of Atlantis did 6 years ago, but it's still good. Also minus 1/2 a point for retarded AI.

Spiral 2
11-15-1999, 07:57 PM
9. I love the controls, much better than Tomb Raider.

Techno Ry
11-15-1999, 10:42 PM
I give it an 187.26... CAN'T WAIT FOR MY COPY TO SHIP!!!!!!

The speed of time is one second per second

11-16-1999, 05:41 AM
Hmm... overall 8/10. Individual ratings:

Atmosphere 9/10 (one point off for not having Harrison Ford's face/voice)
Graphics 9/10 (it's not UT/Q3 but still just fine)
Sound 8/10 (they get the job done, but could be much better)
Difficulty 7/10 (almost perfect, but the hardest level isn't very hard and too many people won't get past the first room)
Documentation 6/10 (no mention of pulling/pushing objects)
Controls 6/10 (playable but not what they could have been, overly unforgiving)
AI 4/10 http://www.indyjones.net/forums/frown.gif (bouncing sharks, Commie pathing, the list goes on and on)