LucasForums

LucasForums (http://www.lucasforums.com/index.php)
-   Prequel Trilogy (http://www.lucasforums.com/forumdisplay.php?f=439)
-   -   Gen. Kenobi, years ago you served my father in the Clone Wars... (http://www.lucasforums.com/showthread.php?t=155521)

Kurgan 11-16-2005 11:12 PM

Gen. Kenobi, years ago you served my father in the Clone Wars...
 
Going by Leia's holographic message to Obi-Wan given to him in Episode IV: A New Hope... is this another continuity flaw or plot hole?

I don't recall anything in the prequels that could be construed as Kenobi "serving" Bail Organa. They had a copule of short conversations at the end of the film (near the end of the war) but Organa was a Senator, and I don't recall that Obi-Wan even ever set foot on Alderaan.

About the only thing I can think of is that he "served" Organa in the generic sense of the Jedi Council "serving" the will of the Senate and the Republic, despite having some kind of autonomy (they also apparently serve the Chancellor, according to Episode I). By by that logic he "served" every single one of those thousands (?) of senators we see just as well. Was Kenobi ever a part of the Rebellion? I haven't watched the deleted scenes, but somehow I doubt he's in the ones where they talk about forming a rebellion. Apparently after Episode III he just dropped of Luke and went into exile there on Tatooine... and stayed there until the next episode.. right?

Or is Leia trying to butter him up by being overly flowery in her speech?

Anyway, I'm just curious if anybody else noticed this...

El Sitherino 11-16-2005 11:14 PM

Well obviously she's kissing his ass, but with reason. He's an aging jedi knight and he is her only hope (you heard the line :p).

Kurgan 11-17-2005 12:17 AM

"General Kenobi, years ago you single handedly won the clone wars and saved my father's a$$... plus might I add that you are quite a handsome man, and if not for your Jedi vows... let's just say, 'I'd hit it.' Also, I've got tickets to Galaxy Bowl MCMLXXVII..."

RedHawke 11-17-2005 01:52 AM

^^^^
:lol:

I never even noticed that, it definately is a little bit of a stretch, but I guess it seems possible, or possibly it was a code of some kind to tell Obi-Wan to come out of hiding? :giveup:

Sabretooth 11-17-2005 06:42 AM

She wanted to anger Obi so that he'll actually come out to the Death Star for her. He wouldn't have cared otherwise.

Astrotoy7 11-17-2005 11:09 AM

You gotta think about it like this:

ROYAL HOUSE OF ALDERAAN - INT - THRONE ROOM
[Young Princess Leia Organa sits beside an aging Bail Organa]

LEIA: Tell me about the clone wars father

BAIL ORGANA: The Clone Wars was a terrible time in the history of the republic, young Leia. From right under our noses, the Emperor manipulated the senate to create an army to serve his own needs.

LEIA: Were there many battles ?

BAIL ORGANA : Yes, too many than I care to remember.....

LEIA: And the jedi ?

BAIL ORGANA: Yes, the jedi were valiant warriors, who in the end were betrayed by Palpatine, and by one of their own kind.

LEIA: Did you know many jedi ?

BAIL ORGANA: Yes. But after the great purge, there remained but two jedi. Only I know their location, and indeed they would come out of exile to help me if I called upon them.....remember this Leia, for one day you may need to call upon them to aid us in our struggle...

LEIA: Yes, father

Thats not too much of a stretch is it ??

mtfbwya

SirLancelot 11-17-2005 12:17 PM

I think she was being figurative. Baal Organa was one of the original creators of the Rebel Alliance. Since Obi-Wan ultimately served the ideals of the Old Republic, that Baal Organa held to, I guess you can say that Obi-Wan did "serve him".

Just my thoughts.

Kurgan 11-17-2005 02:50 PM

Leia sure is gullable for a Senator/Princess! Not only did she "remember her real mother" but she also thinks Obi-Wan served her father. Why doesn't she remember Obi-Wan "through the Force" like her mother? After all, she probably spent more time with him than with Padme! (post-birth anyway)

SirLancelot 11-17-2005 05:47 PM

Aren't we splitting hairs here? LOL!

I mean I wonder why PRINCESS Leia was a Princess when her father was not a king, but a Senator. I wonder why the QUEEN of Naboo is an elected official, why not call him/her prime minister or president?

It's just one of those Star Wars "things". :-)

Still, the thoeries put forth by some here are very plausible.

MachineCult 11-17-2005 05:51 PM

They probably called her QUEEN Amidala to justify Leia being a Princess.

SirLancelot 11-17-2005 05:58 PM

Why would they do that when Leia was not even born yet? The office of QUEEN of Naboo is an elected position. Padme Amidala was no longer queen when Leia was born, she was a Senator. Padme called her successor "Queen" so it was not just a courtesy title for Padme it was the title of the occupant of her office.

Also, Vader called Leia Your Highness in Episode IV, a title of royalty. This was when he didn't even know about the twins, Luke and Leia, thus making Leia his daughter. As far as he knew, she was the daughter of Senator Baal Organa of Alderaan.

Like I said, a Star Wars "thing". :-)

MachineCult 11-17-2005 06:23 PM

You don't understand what i'm saying.

They had already called Leia a Princess when they began the Prequels, even though it was an elected position, they didn't want the OT to seem even more different to the PT, with senators having royal titles, so they gave a character with an elected position a royal title as well.

SirLancelot 11-17-2005 07:00 PM

I see. I think that's reaching a bit, but . . .in the end, it worked.

TK-8252 11-17-2005 08:19 PM

Alderaan has a queen. Just not a king.

That's how Naboo is too.

SirLancelot 11-17-2005 08:43 PM

Right, but Leia was not the daughter of the queen.

TK-8252 11-17-2005 08:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SirLancelot
Right, but Leia was not the daughter of the queen.

Step-daughter.

El Sitherino 11-17-2005 09:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MachineCult
They probably called her QUEEN Amidala to justify Leia being a Princess.

No, they called her queen to tie in that politics/royalty is a family thing. ;)

SirLancelot 11-17-2005 10:24 PM

Something I just found out recently. Senator Bail Organa was the head of the Royal Family of Alderan. That explains it then. I never really looked into his background. So that is why she is a Princess.

Interesting, as the head of the royal family he is also the delegate for Alderan in the Senate. That's not a position held by the head of state, usually. Another Star Wars "thing", apparently.

The Source 12-01-2005 06:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kurgan
Going by Leia's holographic message to Obi-Wan given to him in Episode IV: A New Hope... is this another continuity flaw or plot hole?

I don't recall anything in the prequels that could be construed as Kenobi "serving" Bail Organa. They had a copule of short conversations at the end of the film (near the end of the war) but Organa was a Senator, and I don't recall that Obi-Wan even ever set foot on Alderaan.

About the only thing I can think of is that he "served" Organa in the generic sense of the Jedi Council "serving" the will of the Senate and the Republic, despite having some kind of autonomy (they also apparently serve the Chancellor, according to Episode I). By by that logic he "served" every single one of those thousands (?) of senators we see just as well. Was Kenobi ever a part of the Rebellion? I haven't watched the deleted scenes, but somehow I doubt he's in the ones where they talk about forming a rebellion. Apparently after Episode III he just dropped of Luke and went into exile there on Tatooine... and stayed there until the next episode.. right?

Or is Leia trying to butter him up by being overly flowery in her speech?

Anyway, I'm just curious if anybody else noticed this...

If you think about it, General Kenobi did serve with her father in the Clone Wars. I wonder if Lucas had an after thought about how to approach the relationships!?!?

Edit: After Thought:: Maybe her adopted family told her tidbits about her actual family???

Another Thought:: Why did she remember slight images of Padame, and Luke has no memory of her!?!?

RobQel-Droma 12-01-2005 07:27 PM

I just thought she was being figurative. I pretty much agree with Astrotoy with the conversation, I bet something like that happened.

johnnyoi 12-09-2005 12:18 PM

The jedi served the senate in the republic days. So technically it's correct.

MachineCult 12-10-2005 12:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by johnnyoi
The jedi served the senate in the republic days. So technically it's correct.

I agree, but if some people don't except that explanation, then it's just the tinyest plot hole ever.

TK-1818 12-10-2005 09:14 PM

When Leia was describing her 'mother' to Luke, I originally compared that she was just describing her step mother. Another star wars 'thing' because Lucas never did establish a prelude before he started the first of the OT. Anyway, Baal Organa was killed during the explosion of Alderran so that would initially make Leia Queen or Princess of whatever is left. And besides, and Empire has and Emperor and/or an Empress. I don't know if it's called Prince or Princess but if she is the Princess then wouldn't the Emperor be her father. Unless ofcourse Lucas originally intended Leia to know Vader was her father and that's why she is PRINCESS and Vader is LORD vader.

El Sitherino 12-11-2005 09:55 AM

She's the princess because she is part of the Alderaan noble family. Her step-mother, Bail's wife, was Queen.

RoxStar 12-18-2005 10:44 PM

Shes humbling him.

Or Lucas didn't really know what he was going to do with the two at the time. (The two being Organa and Obi Wan)


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 07:04 PM.

Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
LFNetwork, LLC ©2002-2011 - All rights reserved.