Prehaps. But the way he expresses it is bad, and his arguments, awful and petty.
If he'd posted "I have some severe doubts about this game" rather that "why this game will suck" (Confusing his opinion with the truth) I'd have had more respect.
If his reasons were slightly better than "They didn't use my template and theres no PT" I'd have more respect.
If he'd posted after we had slightly more that a few screenshots and previews. I'd have more respect.
"Your life does flash before your eyes before you die..... the process is called LIVING"