I've done a quick tally. These are not the results.
Best Character: Tie between "Ryan Pano" and "Lt./Capt. Wefive"
Best Plot: The Plight of Darkness
Best Plot Twist: No lead
Most Original/Creative Fanfic: The Adventures of John Skywalker
Most Addictive Fanfic: The Plight of Darkness (OMG 5 Votes!!!)
Best Written/Best Grammar: Tie between "Hidden Shades of Grey" and RC 1162
Best Writer: ForceFightWME12
Best Fanfic: The Plight of Darkness