I haven't played Fire Emblem, but I reckon the series is pretty popular.
But between the other games... yeah, I guess EaW deserved it. That's not much of a competition though.
I haven't played BFME2 extensively, but my cousin did. He told me it was great, way better than the first one, but that some aspects of the game were still too superficial (therefore the game lacks depth that would allow the player to really stick to it for a long time). Most of the internet reviews weren't that kind with it either.
I personally think that Civilization 4 deserved to win (was it even nominated?). It's an awesome game, way better than Civ 3 and any of the other finalists.
~Dark Cupcake of the Sith
Last edited by Darth54; 08-09-2006 at 10:49 PM.