Aha. Chickening out, huh? :~~
I did not say believing something to be supernatural makes it so. And as a non religious and knowing person I put doubt in pretty much anything I "know" to be "true". Hence whenever I experience something special while having a "supernatural experience", I may think of it being possibly contact to god. Next to other possibilities like hallucinations or maybe even a Total Recall scenario. Without proof, I surely would shrug it off with "can't figure it out" and carry on.
However, in case I ever blame something to be some god's work it would not mean I'm gonna worship that god or follow any religion.