Drop whatever you're doing and go read Crime and Punishment! Although, I'm a lot like you, I want to first finish the books I have on the shelf before moving on to new ones. Right now I'm in a Russian phase, and I want to finish those books before moving back to Discworld or maybe Poirot books. That'll take a while though, I've still got three more books of Russian literature to go through in my boxed set, and then the 3 Dostoevsky books I bought because I liked Crime and Punishment so much (Poor Folk, The Idiot, The Brothers Karamazov), and Diary of a Madman and other stories by Gogol. And I've got hundreds of books on my Amazon wish list...
Also, that's an impressive backlog you've got there, Kroms. I hope you'll manage to read through them some time soon! (Although reading shouldn't feel like a chore.)