Originally Posted by Alexrd
By ignoring a whole (good and important) movie, I'd say his reasoning is pretty damn bad.
I'm... assuming you mean TPM, the "good and important" part is throwing me off lol.
I watched the order he suggested and it seemed to work, with the only problem being the mentioning of Qui-Gonn during a few occasions. The lack of detail about the events without viewing TPM end up feeling like ANH does at the start with all of this pre-established stuff you haven't really heard about but have apparently happened so it works in that regard.
And yeah, he acknowledges in his entry that someone did come up with the order of 4, 5, 1, 2, 3, 6 before him.... if you actually read the entry.