Originally Posted by Bob Saget
You're forgetting that this is an alternate timeline where the stories and events proceed differently. I.E. This movie, if you've seen it.
No, I'm not forgetting anything, and I don't need to be reminded that it's an alternate timeline.
There were parts of the plot I liked, and parts I didn't - the overall idea of bringing the character back I'm fine with. But again, I don't like the way they went about it.
For instance -
Kirk dies. Ok, that's dramatic (even if the manner in which he dies was poorly thought out), I guess. If only they hadn't already set up the get-out clause an hour earlier with the dead Tribble.
And reversing the roles in the aforementioned scene smacks of laziness. And the less said about Spock's outburst, the better.
However, Section 31 was a terrible idea in DS9/Enterprise, but I can see how it would work well in the more militarised alternate timeline.
And a niggling point - when you're being chased by a pissed off Vulcan through San Francisco, is it really important to stop a grab a trench-coat?
Also, 'Kronos' is spelt with a 'Q'.