Just compare his face on these images and ignore the different graphicstyles
Is that the same guy?
That would be a better direction to "cartoonize" the old Guybrush.
I don't have anything against the CMI graphicstyle in general,but unlike LeChuck,Wally,Elaine etc,Guybrush has gotten out of Proportion.
He's simply too.....long.
The feeling,when playing CMI is like if a new actor plays the role of the hero in your favourite Movie series.....
Still can't cope with that.