lfnetwork.com mark read register faq members calendar
View Poll Results: Who would Win? Whos Strongest? (two different questions i guess)
Team 1 9 18.37%
Team 2 18 36.73%
Team 3 5 10.20%
Team 4 3 6.12%
Team 5 14 28.57%
Voters: 49. You may not vote on this poll


Thread: Dark Side Battle Royal
Thread Tools Display Modes
Post a new thread. Add a reply to this thread. Indicate all threads in this forum as read. Subscribe to this forum. RSS feed: this forum RSS feed: all forums
Old 08-14-2009, 05:01 PM   #81
Gob
Rookie
 
Gob's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: Super Awesome Land
Posts: 166
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lord of Hunger View Post
The problem is...who do they have in their lifetimes to compare to? They (Yoda and Vader) haven't actually experienced the power of the other Sith to be unbiased.
Those quotes weren't from Yoda and Vader's perspectives, because they're not novels. It was the author speaking.

Quote:
Give me an example of something that Sidious has done that no one else has, aside from forming the Galactic Empire (which he did not by any means do on his own and merely assisted in its eventual formation). Force Powers? Nothing original. Kill almost every Jedi? Triumvirate did that? Immortality? Sion, Nihilus, and Andeddu got that down. Force Storm? Others have done it. Powerful apprentice? Nothing new yet again.
Name one other Sith that has been able to create a Force storm. Also, name one other Sith that has been described on multiple occasions to be "the most powerful Sith Lord in history."

Quote:
Fact is, Sidious did little more than copy the deeds of beings far greater than him. He convinced the Republic to become something it was already headed towards. Revan actually managed to convert people, alter loyalties and the like. Manipulate minds and perception? Darth Traya did that 4000 years before him.
The Republic was "heading towards" the state of Empire because of Sidious. Darth Traya manipulated the Exile and Sion. Impressive. Sidious managed to manipulate the Republic so that he controlled it, as well as the CIS. Not a single Jedi managed to uncover what he was doing. Traya didn't even succeed in her plan.

Quote:
And ultimately his deeds served to create a Jedi Order far greater than the first one. The Old Jedi Order would have never survived the Vong, but Luke and company did after taking out countless other enemies...including Palpatine's empire.
Of course the NJO was greater than the OJO. Yoda acknowledged that the Jedi would have to change to survive. The NJO didn't take out the Empire. That was Luke. If Luke didn't redeem Vader, Palpatine wouldn't have died, and the Empire would continue as it was.

Gob is offline   you may: quote & reply,
Old 08-14-2009, 05:12 PM   #82
Ping
Elementary.
 
Ping's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: Pennsylvania
Posts: 784
Roleplayer 
Quote:
Mockery: "Oh Master, the Mandalorians are committing massive genocide but I care not because they aren't Sith. Oh look! SITH! People in black carrying red lightsabers! Initiating assassination protocols!"
I do believe that the Jedi realized that the Mandos were being manipulated, but they didn't realize it was the True Sith. Also, the reason the Jedi didn't fight the Mandos are actually plainly stated in both KOTOR games (more so in TSL). However, Revan seemed to leave planets undefended just to get more followers from the genocide/brutality that would result. I'm going to say that while the Jedi Order wasn't very wise in this (I think we can all agree that the Mandos would probably have wiped them out after the Republic), it seems to me that they comitted the lesser of two evils.


"There is no such thing as coincidence, only inevitability" - xxxHoLiC

"Justice? But I don't serve justice, Watson, I serve the truth." - Sherlock Holmes
Ping is offline   you may: quote & reply,
Old 08-15-2009, 04:58 AM   #83
Lord of Hunger
Hunger, The Lord Of
 
Lord of Hunger's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Korriban, Sith Empire
Posts: 1,022
Current Game: Shogun 2: Total War
Quote:
I do believe that the Jedi realized that the Mandos were being manipulated, but they didn't realize it was the True Sith. Also, the reason the Jedi didn't fight the Mandos are actually plainly stated in both KOTOR games (more so in TSL). However, Revan seemed to leave planets undefended just to get more followers from the genocide/brutality that would result. I'm going to say that while the Jedi Order wasn't very wise in this (I think we can all agree that the Mandos would probably have wiped them out after the Republic), it seems to me that they comitted the lesser of two evils.
Did you know that the Jedi Council deliberately silenced knowledge of the Genocide on Cathar from the rest of the Jedi? It was a deliberate attempt to prevent the opposition within the Order from getting a key reason to defy the Council. Ultimately, the whole thing was not about the well-being of the Galaxy but about preserving the power of the Masters over the Students.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gob
Also, name one other Sith that has been described on multiple occasions to be "the most powerful Sith Lord in history."
That's what we call hyperbole. I could be described as the world's greatest storyline consultant on multiple occasions and while I wish it were true it doesn't make me such.

For 1,000 years the Galaxy hadn't faced a decent Sith Lord and I admit his knowledge and power was extensive. But it wasn't anything special or new. If anything, most of Yoda's awe at Palpatine was due to his own surprise at how much the Sith had changed tactics. The Jedi had been preparing to fight the Brotherhood of Darkness all over again, but instead they were faced with a completely different strategy.
Quote:
The Republic was "heading towards" the state of Empire because of Sidious.
Incorrect, the sentiment of the Core Worlds was not in favor of the Republic and its ideals. They wanted nationalism and humanocentrism and core world supremacy and so on. The Separatists, meanwhile, were already very distrustful of the Jedi and the Republic. Sidious merely engineered one scenario to send them into conflict...one of many possibilities.
Quote:
Darth Traya manipulated the Exile and Sion. Impressive. Sidious managed to manipulate the Republic so that he controlled it, as well as the CIS. Not a single Jedi managed to uncover what he was doing. Traya didn't even succeed in her plan.
There is a difference between manipulating someone to act against their normal behavior pattern or interests and manipulating a bunch of people to do what they were already head towards doing. The fact that the Jedi did not manage to uncover his plot is predictable. The Old Jedi Order is historical for its lack of awareness.

And as for Darth Traya not succeeding...think again. She had three goals:

1) Defeat the Jedi ideologically. This was a success as she showed how someone could live without the Force and that they were weak because they relied on it.

2) Create a Force Wound to destroy the Force. Barely failed as a result of her protege.

3) If 2 fails, make sure that the Last of the Jedi learn from the Exile how to live less dependent on the Force. Success, as the Exile's companions went on to rebuild the Order. We do see the movie era Old Jedi Order as having more training in real-life skills rather than its absolute dependence on the Force as shown in the KOTOR series.

She succeed in two/three goals. Pretty good, considering Palpatine merely wiped away a crumbling Jedi Order and decadent Republic and ended up giving rise to the infinitely superior New Jedi Order and many of the greatest heroes of the Galaxy. Kinda backfired, didn't it?


As of 3/14/10, TSL is restored. The Sith Lords Restored Content Modification by Stoney and Zbyl has been finished and can be downloaded here.

Lord of Hunger is offline   you may: quote & reply,
Old 08-15-2009, 10:33 AM   #84
Gurges-Ahter
Tyler Durden
 
Gurges-Ahter's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Parker, TX
Posts: 953
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lord of Hunger View Post
Pretty good, considering Palpatine merely wiped away a crumbling Jedi Order and decadent Republic ...
You're going through this argument with blinders on. The only reason the Jedi Order was "crumbling" at all, if you can call it that, was because of Palpatine.


Gurges-Ahter is offline   you may: quote & reply,
Old 08-15-2009, 11:30 AM   #85
Gob
Rookie
 
Gob's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: Super Awesome Land
Posts: 166
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lord of Hunger View Post
That's what we call hyperbole. I could be described as the world's greatest storyline consultant on multiple occasions and while I wish it were true it doesn't make me such.
It wasn't hyperbole because it was purely objective, from the point of the author. Information from a C-canon source is considered canon, unless it conflicts with G-canon. No other Sith has feats that match Palpatine's. Bane has lightning that rivals his, but that's it. Nihilus could use an ability to suck the life out of planets, but at the cost of his own body and humanity. Sidious didn't want to make that sacrifice, because he knew the implications of the technique. Traya can use Force drain to kill some Jedi Masters, who aren't even as strong as the PT Jedi. Palpatine killed three PT Jedi, with Mace Windu attacking him as well. Sion can regenerate himself, but can be broken through words. Palpatine could create Force storms, which took the combined power of Luke, Leia, and Anakin Solo's potential to even throw off course.

Quote:
For 1,000 years the Galaxy hadn't faced a decent Sith Lord and I admit his knowledge and power was extensive. But it wasn't anything special or new. If anything, most of Yoda's awe at Palpatine was due to his own surprise at how much the Sith had changed tactics. The Jedi had been preparing to fight the Brotherhood of Darkness all over again, but instead they were faced with a completely different strategy.
It says in the Dark Empire Sourcebook that Palpatine had gathered the greatest works of knowledge from even the most obscure sources, and studied the Force in all of its aspects.

It is true that Yoda was surprised at the evolution of the Sith, but he was also more powerful than any Jedi before him. He could match Palpatine in raw Force power, but could not defeat him.

Quote:
Incorrect, the sentiment of the Core Worlds was not in favor of the Republic and its ideals. They wanted nationalism and humanocentrism and core world supremacy and so on. The Separatists, meanwhile, were already very distrustful of the Jedi and the Republic. Sidious merely engineered one scenario to send them into conflict...one of many possibilities.
As well as controlling the entire war. He manipulated a Jedi Master into ordering billions of clone troopers, which would later become stormtroopers. He managed to get into the position of power over the CIS, which he hadn't had control over before. He wasn't born into control over the two driving forces of the galaxy; he had to get there himself. And he did.

Gob is offline   you may: quote & reply,
Old 08-15-2009, 01:35 PM   #86
Darth_Yuthura
Banned
 
Status: Banned
Join Date: May 2008
Location: Vienna
Posts: 1,585
Current Game: KOTOR III
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gob View Post
No other Sith has feats that match Palpatine's. Bane has lightning that rivals his, but that's it. Nihilus could use an ability to suck the life out of planets, but at the cost of his own body and humanity. Sidious didn't want to make that sacrifice, because he knew the implications of the technique. Traya can use Force drain to kill some Jedi Masters, who aren't even as strong as the PT Jedi. Palpatine killed three PT Jedi, with Mace Windu attacking him as well. Sion can regenerate himself, but can be broken through words. Palpatine could create Force storms, which took the combined power of Luke, Leia, and Anakin Solo's potential to even throw off course.
Very scientific reasoning, considering that Palpatine had gone up against Darth Bane... wait he didn't? How would you know that?

Three masters that weren't as strong as the PT Jedi you say? I remember something that mentioned ancient Force-users actually were more powerful than those from the present. That actually inverses your logic.

Palpatine didn't go up against four Council members, he took on one Council member, one master, and two knights. I actually believe that due to the release issues, Master Vash was supposed to also be on Dantooine, but even three council members would have been more than Palpatine could handle. Given as he struggled against Windu, I would place my bets on Kreia. She killed three Council members with extreme ease, where Palpatine couldn't even beat Windu alone. (Yes there were three other Jedi, but they didn't aid Windu much)

Sion wasn't broken through words... he just wanted to die when he realized his life of pain wasn't worth living.

Nihilus actually became stronger as more powerful opponents got in his way. His hunger was his strength, so long as there were beings worth consuming. He would have died anyway, but not after being the last 'living' thing in the galaxy.
Darth_Yuthura is offline   you may: quote & reply,
Old 08-15-2009, 02:21 PM   #87
Lord of Hunger
Hunger, The Lord Of
 
Lord of Hunger's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Korriban, Sith Empire
Posts: 1,022
Current Game: Shogun 2: Total War
Quote:
You're going through this argument with blinders on. The only reason the Jedi Order was "crumbling" at all, if you can call it that, was because of Palpatine.
Tell me, did you even READ my arguments at all? I'm afraid that it is you who are going through this argument with blinders on because if your read my argument you would know that the Jedi Order was decaying long before Palpatine was around.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gob
It wasn't hyperbole because it was purely objective, from the point of the author. Information from a C-canon source is considered canon, unless it conflicts with G-canon.
Mockery: Oh Master, this guy is the most uber 1337 dude ever because someone SAYS so without providing consistent evidence against the new facts that say otherwise.

Hang onto the holy movies however much you want, doesn't change that a) the prequels are universally considered poorly made by anyone with good taste and b) there have been hundreds of new revelations about the Star Wars universe in general that make render this proclaimed superiority of Palpatine false.
Quote:
No other Sith has feats that match Palpatine's. Bane has lightning that rivals his, but that's it.
Uh...thought bomb? Then again, that was Revan's technique to begin with....
Quote:
Nihilus could use an ability to suck the life out of planets, but at the cost of his own body and humanity. Sidious didn't want to make that sacrifice, because he knew the implications of the technique.
Doesn't change the fact that Sidious would be nothing but a well-cooked steak to Nihilus.
Quote:
Traya can use Force drain to kill some Jedi Masters, who aren't even as strong as the PT Jedi. Palpatine killed three PT Jedi, with Mace Windu attacking him as well.
Please, despite their flaws any Master of that time could have kicked Windu's ***. Especially Kavar, the great Weapon Master who could have lead the Jedi in the Mandalorian Wars. And I'd like to Palpy try and drain Vrook, given that guy's iron discipline.
Quote:
Sion can regenerate himself, but can be broken through words.
Sion essentially was the closest thing to immortal: it was his decision alone to die that could kill him.
Quote:
Palpatine could create Force storms, which took the combined power of Luke, Leia, and Anakin Solo's potential to even throw off course.
Again, the all-important Force Storms that HE CAN'T EVEN CONTROL. It's like saying that someone is awesome because they can wildly fire a gun in random directions.
Quote:
It says in the Dark Empire Sourcebook that Palpatine had gathered the greatest works of knowledge from even the most obscure sources, and studied the Force in all of its aspects.
Lashowe could have taken the Sith Holocron of Tulak Hord and barely learned anything from it without even knowing it. Just because you have access to superior knowledge doesn't mean you'll fully understand it. Palpatine could have been granted all the holocrons of Malachor and he would never be able to learn Force Vampiricy without having a decent understanding of the Ancient Sith techniques themselves. That knowledge was limited to the Ancient/True Sith and a few select others.
Quote:
It is true that Yoda was surprised at the evolution of the Sith, but he was also more powerful than any Jedi before him. He could match Palpatine in raw Force power, but could not defeat him.
And what is your evidence for Yoda being so powerful, hm?
Quote:
As well as controlling the entire war. He manipulated a Jedi Master into ordering billions of clone troopers, which would later become stormtroopers. He managed to get into the position of power over the CIS, which he hadn't had control over before. He wasn't born into control over the two driving forces of the galaxy; he had to get there himself. And he did.
Convincing a whole bunch of weak-minded individuals and one Jedi Master to engage in a conflict the Galaxy is already heading towards. Yeah, great achievement in comparison to Revan, the guy who converted thousands to a completely different system of beliefs and not only nearly brought about the physical collapse of the Republic but also its spiritual collapse.


As of 3/14/10, TSL is restored. The Sith Lords Restored Content Modification by Stoney and Zbyl has been finished and can be downloaded here.

Lord of Hunger is offline   you may: quote & reply,
Old 08-15-2009, 02:28 PM   #88
TKA-001
I sneer at thee.
 
TKA-001's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2005
Posts: 1,535
Forum Veteran 
Quote:
Except the source I have cited, and even the all important arguments of George Lucas that the nature of the Dark Side is parasitism. It only makes sense that one of the greatest dark side Empires practiced that belief.
Why does what makes sense to you mean that that is canon? Your only basis for that is taking a statement form George Lucas out of context into an illogical conclusion.

Quote:
Again, see my evidence.
You have no evidence. Your argument of the Ancient Sith all being "Force Vampires" can be likened to the old fan theory that Darth Nihilus was actually a result of the Jedi Exile's soul splitting in half and the dark side of it taking root in some Jedi's corpse at Malachor: A bunch of random details taken out of context and wrapped together into a conclusion that falls flat on its face.

Quote:
Kreia: If you were to face an Ancient Sith Lord in combat you would find that we are as but children playing with toys.

And don't give me the whole "KREIA ALWAYS LIES!!!!1!" deal again...why would she lie about this.
I don't see why Kreia would lie. Another thing I don't see is how the hell Kreia would know anything about the power level of ancient Sith and Jedi relative to Sith and Jedi during the First Jedi Purge. Kreia certainly wasn't alive back then. How would she even be able to compare them?

Quote:
In fact, it is apparent that the Jedi Order over time declined from what it was during the Great Hyperspace War as the Jedi Masters became increasingly arrogant and the Jedi in general became
Even if the exaggerated accusations you make about Jedi arrogance and Jedi evil are all true, they would not make them weaker in the Force or combat.

Quote:
more dependent on the Force instead of real-life skills, thus actually decreasing their Force potential.
Oh. So I guess Anakin Skywalker's skill with machines and piloting vehicles, crime-investigation proficiency of the likes of Obi-Wan Kenobi and Jax Pavan, and the standard diplomacy skills that Jedi were so favored by the Republic government for don't count as "real-life" skills, then?

Quote:
Meanwhile the Ancient Sith both had armies of Force Sensitive Massassi Warriors and Kissai priests to serve them.
I don't see much evidence of brilliant proficiency of the Massassi or above any other type of soldier (it might or might not be worth mentioning that they were all enslaved single-handedly by one Sith, Exar Kun), or of the Kissai above any other type of sufficiently-experience Force-user.

Quote:
[Kreia] could not only hide her aura, but her presence too.
So what? So could Palpatine.

Quote:
And she could remotely control memories, send telepathic messages across the Galaxy. Do Palpatine's abilities reach that far?
Actually, yes. Palpatine had telepathic connections to a number of (or all, not sure on how many) his Emperor's Hands, which he could use to issue orders, among other things. The most well-known example, of course, is Mara Jade. Palpatine also temporarily transferred his spirit into the body of Jeng Droga, another Emperor's Hand.

Quote:
More like he [Sion] reattaches those body parts and then uses Force Crush on whoever did it.
That's ****ing stupid. I refuse to believe that that is possible. There is no actual evidence given in TSL for that, besides.

Quote:
Because Bane was the very founder of Palpy's Order. Palpy's techniques were acquired either through Holocrons or the teachings of Darth Bane that were passed on and refined over time.
More handwaving. This does not actually explain your hypothesis at all. Furthermore, what special techniques did Palpatine use that he learned from before? More importantly, why does that make him any weaker?

Quote:
Considering you had a Force Blackhole (Exile), some mortal (Mandalore), and his former apprentice (Visas), he had no reason to consume them immediately. If Palpatine was there instead, Nihilus' reaction would have been "FOODFOODFOODFOOD!!! OM NOM NOM NOM NOM NOM!!!"

Okay, I admit that was a bit silly but I think you get my point.
You can't know that for sure. I freely admit that it is possible that Nihilus' attention is more easily aroused by the presence of multiple powerful Force-users, but that is only conjecture. We have only one event known where Nihilus directs his drainage power toward an individual, and in that case, the Exile had to be standing within spitting distance of Nihilus before the Dark Lord even noticed her/his presence. Not enough of Nihilus has been seen in order to determine exactly how his power works.

Quote:
Shooting him in the back would have done nothing. There was no flesh: he was a spirit, some robes, and armor. They would have singed his robe and right after would have been attacked.
If there was no flesh, then how do you explain Nihilus being killed by the Exile's lightsaber if there was no flesh to cut and no vital organs to sever?

Quote:
What are these accomplishments you keep talking about? The Jedi Order at that time was PATHETIC, just as blinded by their own hubris
More exaggeration about how wimpy the Jedi Order supposedly was. Palpatine spend decades manipulating himself into becoming the head of state of the Republic by means which as far as everyone else knew was legitimate. He staged galactic crises and conflicts to solidify his power, evaded detection from the Jedi this whole time, turned one of the Jedi Order's most powerful Jedi into his apprentice... Why am I typing this paragraph? We both know Palpatine's achievements.

Quote:
The Republic was already on its way to becoming like the Empire.
So what? It never would have gotten there if he hadn't declared the Empire himself. And while the Republic was corrupt by the time of The Phantom Menace, I think it is quite a stretch to say that it would have eventually turned out as bad as the Empire without Palpy's influence.

Quote:
He was defeated by his half dead apprentice throwing him into a reactor core
So you're saying that the Ancient Sith Lords were immune to being thrown down neigh-bottomless pits.

Quote:
then again by two junior Jedi Knights.
He was defeated because they cut off his connection to the dark side, not because they were superior to him in Force strength.

Quote:
All the damage that was ever dealt to the Alliance was through Imperial Forces, not by him.
What's that supposed to mean? Should Palpatine be running around with his lightsaber charging at rebel installations and bases in the Outer Rim all the time?

Quote:
Their [the four Jedi's] defeat was a JOKE.
Whether you like it or not, Kit Fisto, Agen Kolar, Saesee Tiin, and Mace Windu have all been repeatedly cited as masters in their areas of lightsaber combat, and your argument that they are significantly weaker than previous generations of Jedi does not hold up.

Quote:
So you think that the clones would have won the Battle of the Jedi Temple that quickly and easily without Anakin, or at all? Anakin managed to take down their greatest lightsaber duelist, who would have managed to rally a significant defense.
Granted, without Vader's help in killing key Jedi Masters, the fight would have been more difficult, but it only would have meant some heavier clone trooper casualties, and to a galaxy-spanning Empire, the lives of a few thousands clone troopers are nothing. As we see in Attack of the Clones, even large groups of Force users can be brought down if you spam them with foot soldiers enough. Besides, even if they did defeat the entire infantry force sent at the temple, the Republic army would just use a Star Destroyer to level the temple from low orbit. Given the resources at the Republic's disposal, there was no possible way to lose Operation Knightfall unless they gave up.

Quote:
Then why didn't he just stick with Dooku, a far more refined individual?
Because Palpatine loves power. He wants the most powerful Empire, the most powerful personal strength in the Force, and therefore the most powerful apprentice available.

Quote:
The Galactic Empire was actually more decentralized than the Galactic Republic. Systems were grouped in sectors and sectors in turn into oversectors. These were controlled by the Moffs and Grand Moffs, who exercised power in the disparate regions of the galaxy. This was in contrast to the structure of the Galactic Republic, which placed senators in control of their respective sectors.

The Imperial Ruling Council was the name given to the group of Imperial Advisors who constituted the most powerful collective body in the galaxy during the New Order. While Palpatine was Emperor, it was the Council that managed the Empire and carried out his will. After his death, it became the effective central government of the Empire.
Wookieepedia says that the Empire was more decentralized, so it was. That statement isn't sourced. More to the point, how is the above information indicative of decentralized power?

Quote:
Yeah, that is so whity. If you are trying to make me feel like somehow my arguments are poorly constructed and you are an expert on this field, you are not succeeding.
My apologies. Our debate would be more enjoyable without my using provocative language.

Quote:
They were already researching even more powerful weapons. I sincerely doubt that the Death Star I was the only one that they would have built. To quote one man: "The Emperor had little of anything built only once."
Hair-splitting. There's no way that a superweapon arms race would start within the Empire without the Emperor's knowledge.

Quote:
YET. What happens when the equally overhyped Thrawn combines Imperial Forces with the tech and resources of the Chiss Ascendancy? How long does Palpatine last against a strategist like that with such an army?
Why would such a situation arise in the first place? Thrawn didn't have any plans to overthrow the Emperor. His allegiance is to the Empire, and therefore the ruler of the Empire, and therefore Palpatine. The only reason he tried to take control during the Thrawn Trilogy was because there was no Emperor.

Quote:
He was able to deflect his lightning in the same way as Yoda...I'd say that's pretty dang good.
The apprentice's "fight" with Palpatine was a brief trading of Force-related attacks until Palpatine ended up getting stunned. The Emperor was obviously bull****ting the apprentice about how weak he supposedly was. Even in the game's alternate ending, the apprentice is no match for the Emperor.

Quote:
Give me an example of something that Sidious has done that no one else has, aside from forming the Galactic Empire (which he did not by any means do on his own and merely assisted in its eventual formation).
Again, this idea that the Empire would have formed on its own is simply a theory based on exaggerated accusations of Galactic Republic corruption.

Quote:
Kill almost every Jedi? Triumvirate did that?
No other Sith has killed master Jedi swordsman in less time than it takes to blow one's nose.

Quote:
Immortality? Sion, Nihilus, and Andeddu got that down.
I thought Sion was invincible. Incidentally, since we've apparently established that Sion can instantly reattach his severed limbs back onto his body, what would happen if you blasted him with a Star Destroyer's heavy guns? As for Nihilus, since he died from being killed and was in danger of starving to death anyway... No, he wasn't immortal.

Quote:
Force Storm? Others have done it.
Who?

Quote:
Revan actually managed to convert people, alter loyalties and the like. Manipulate minds and perception? Darth Traya did that 4000 years before him.
Palpatine did all of those things just as well. Why does the fact that he isn't the first or only person to do these things make it less impressive?

Quote:
Did you know that the Jedi Council deliberately silenced knowledge of the Genocide on Cathar from the rest of the Jedi? It was a deliberate attempt to prevent the opposition within the Order from getting a key reason to defy the Council. Ultimately, the whole thing was not about the well-being of the Galaxy but about preserving the power of the Masters over the Students.
A less-than-clean aim, to be sure (indeed, the first thing the KotOR-era Jedi do that I agree seems low for them), but I believe that in this case, preserving the "power" of the Jedi Masters over their brash, younger ranks like Revan and Malak would have served a greater good by preventing or stalling their rebellion. That said, I would sincerely appreciate it if we could all keep the matter of First Jedi Order morality or lack thereof out of this debate, because I've already debated it exhaustively with Lord of Hunger and would prefer not to return to previously-trodden ground.

Quote:
Traya can use Force drain to kill some Jedi Masters, who aren't even as strong as the PT Jedi.
To be fair, I don't see much reason to believe the Jedi Civil War-era Jedi were weaker than those of later eras.

Quote:
Palpatine didn't go up against four Council members, he took on one Council member, one master, and two knights.
Nevertheless, all four have been described, portrayed, and demonstrated as being highly proficient swordsman among the best the Jedi Order had.

Quote:
I remember something that mentioned ancient Force-users actually were more powerful than those from the present. That actually inverses your logic.
"Somebody says that somewhere in-universe and it is compatible with my side of the debate, so it is indisputable that it must be true."

Quote:
where Palpatine couldn't even beat Windu alone. (Yes there were three other Jedi, but they didn't aid Windu much)
What you're saying is that because Windu was capable of kicking Palpatine in the face, causing his lightsaber to fly out the window and knocking him to the floor, then Palpatine was definitively incapable of besting Windu in single combat. Not only does that mean that Yoda is considerably weaker than Windu (which is bogus), but it also means that one's skill with a lightsaber and knowledge and proficiency with the Force is dependent on one's ability to suddenly lift one's boot and thrust it forward.

Quote:
He would have died anyway, but not after being the last 'living' thing in the galaxy.
That is extremely unlikely, considering that a galaxy is a very big place, and Nihilus can only be in one place at a time. He would have starved to death before killing off even a fraction of the galaxy's population.

Quote:
Uh...thought bomb? Then again, that was Revan's technique to begin with....
Revan did not invent the thought bomb; It predated him and was likely "invented" by the Ancient Sith. More to the point, a Thought Bomb is no stronger than a Force storm and requires a lot more than just one Sith Lord to utilize.

Quote:
Doesn't change the fact that Sidious would be nothing but a well-cooked steak to Nihilus.
Possibly, but only if Nihilus is capable of perceiving the Emperor soon enough and getting within range... Neither of which we have enough information about to draw a definite conclusion about.

Quote:
Palpatine could have been granted all the holocrons of Malachor and he would never be able to learn Force Vampiricy without having a decent understanding of the Ancient Sith techniques themselves. That knowledge was limited to the Ancient/True Sith and a few select others.
So Palpatine was mentally incapable of understanding these Ancient techniques? Why? Furthermore, what proof do you have that he was incapable?

Quote:
Again, the all-important Force Storms that HE CAN'T EVEN CONTROL.
Dark Empire series says he can partially control them, and he lost control of them only when his connection to the dark side was cut off by Skywalker and his sister. Besides, what powers on that scale can be fully controlled?

Quote:
Yeah, great achievement in comparison to Revan, the guy who converted thousands to a completely different system of beliefs
Revan did the mass-conversion by corrupting the Jedi in the wars and then pushing them over the edge with Malachor. Any master manipulator could have done that, provided they know about Force wounds (and given Revan seems to have known about them without anyone telling him, I don't see why Palpatine couldn't).

Quote:
only nearly brought about the physical collapse of the Republic but also its spiritual collapse.
What is this spiritual collapse which you speak of? And what sources can you cite in regards to how the Republic was practically already the Empire before Palpatine stepped in?

Quote:
Please, despite their flaws any Master of that time could have kicked Windu's ***. Especially Kavar, the great Weapon Master who could have lead the Jedi in the Mandalorian Wars.
You can't say that with any definitiveness because we have no idea how skilled Kavar is other than that he's considered a highly-skilled Weaponmaster, which is far too vague to draw a conclusion from.

Quote:
Hang onto the holy movies however much you want, doesn't change that a) the prequels are universally considered poorly made by anyone with good taste
Not only does that have no bearing on this discussion, it's also (among other things) an extremely bigoted statement to make, which can only serve to make the discussion needlessly heated.

Quote:
you would know that the Jedi Order was decaying long before Palpatine was around.
The supposed moral decay of the Jedi is irrelevant to this discussion, because moral decay does not equal power decay.


"There is something going on in time and space, and beyond time and space, which, whether we like it or not, spells duty." -Winston Churchill

"For of all sad words of tongue or pen, The saddest are these: 'It might have been!'" -John Whittier

"Apathy is death." -Kreia

Last edited by TKA-001; 08-15-2009 at 03:01 PM.
TKA-001 is offline   you may: quote & reply,
Old 08-15-2009, 03:20 PM   #89
Darth_Yuthura
Banned
 
Status: Banned
Join Date: May 2008
Location: Vienna
Posts: 1,585
Current Game: KOTOR III
Quote:
Originally Posted by TKA-001 View Post
I don't see why Kreia would lie. Another thing I don't see is how the hell Kreia would know anything about the power level of ancient Sith and Jedi relative to Sith and Jedi during the First Jedi Purge. Kreia certainly wasn't alive back then. How would she even be able to compare them?
I think that she could read history and wonder how ancient masters could perform certain tasks that she couldn't. It's far more likely she would be telling the truth about being impitent than if she were bragging.

Quote:
Originally Posted by TKA-001 View Post
So what? So could Palpatine.
No, I think it was meant that Kreia could make herself invisible. Palpatine was like a Purloined letter.

Quote:
Originally Posted by TKA-001 View Post
You can't know that for sure. I freely admit that it is possible that Nihilus' attention is more easily aroused by the presence of multiple powerful Force-users, but that is only conjecture. We have only one event known where Nihilus directs his drainage power toward an individual, and in that case, the Exile had to be standing within spitting distance of Nihilus before the Dark Lord even noticed her/his presence. Not enough of Nihilus has been seen in order to determine exactly how his power works.
Katarr. Master Zhar... Master Vandar... and a lot of other Jedi. I only wish Atris were there as well.


Quote:
Originally Posted by TKA-001 View Post
Whether you like it or not, Kit Fisto, Agen Kolar, Saesee Tiin, and Mace Windu have all been repeatedly cited as masters in their areas of lightsaber combat, and your argument that they are significantly weaker than previous generations of Jedi does not hold up.
Maybe, but Windu clearly was the more powerful of the two. Had he had help from one of the other Jedi in order to beat Palpatine, then maybe this holds water; but the other three were cut down early. Had they fought one-on-one to start, Mace wouldn't have suffered any disadvantages by fighting alone.

Quote:
Originally Posted by TKA-001 View Post
Granted, without Vader's help in killing key Jedi Masters, the fight would have been more difficult, but it only would have meant some heavier clone trooper casualties, and to a galaxy-spanning Empire, the lives of a few thousands clone troopers are nothing. As we see in Attack of the Clones, even large groups of Force users can be brought down if you spam them with foot soldiers enough. Besides, even if they did defeat the entire infantry force sent at the temple, the Republic army would just use a Star Destroyer to level the temple from low orbit. Given the resources at the Republic's disposal, there was no possible way to lose Operation Knightfall unless they gave up.
If Anakin had simply not selfishly killed Windu, Order 66 wouldn't have been given and the original trilogy wouldn't have happened.

Anyway, the troops that stormed the Temple were trained exceptionally well and they could have carried out the operation without Anakin.

Quote:
Originally Posted by TKA-001 View Post
Hair-splitting. There's no way that a superweapon arms race would start within the Empire without the Emperor's knowledge.
The Maw installation comes to mind.

Quote:
Originally Posted by TKA-001 View Post
The apprentice's "fight" with Palpatine was a brief trading of Force-related attacks until Palpatine ended up getting stunned. The Emperor was obviously bull****ting the apprentice about how weak he supposedly was. Even in the game's alternate ending, the apprentice is no match for the Emperor.
Oh is this that self-fulfilling argument again? Palpatine wasn't defeated by Windu because he was letting himself almost be killed so that Anakin would save him. He just thought it would be great to toy around with Starkiller and almost let himself get killed again. Is that what you're saying?

Quote:
Originally Posted by TKA-001 View Post
No other Sith has killed master Jedi swordsman in less time than it takes to blow one's nose.
That's not Palpatine's style. He would not engage those Master swordsman if he could just as easily wipe them out with the Force. Clearly he resorted to a lightsaber because that was his only way of defeating those Jedi.

Quote:
Originally Posted by TKA-001 View Post
What you're saying is that because Windu was capable of kicking Palpatine in the face, causing his lightsaber to fly out the window and knocking him to the floor, then Palpatine was definitively incapable of besting Windu in single combat. Not only does that mean that Yoda is considerably weaker than Windu (which is bogus), but it also means that one's skill with a lightsaber and knowledge and proficiency with the Force is dependent on one's ability to suddenly lift one's boot and thrust it forward.
No, it was because Windu could not only defend himself against, but redirect Palpatine's lightning against him. Yoda, Starkiller, and Windu could all do that.
Darth_Yuthura is offline   you may: quote & reply,
Old 08-15-2009, 03:48 PM   #90
Gob
Rookie
 
Gob's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: Super Awesome Land
Posts: 166
Quote:
Originally Posted by Darth_Yuthura View Post
Very scientific reasoning, considering that Palpatine had gone up against Darth Bane... wait he didn't? How would you know that?
Except those quotes saying that Palpatine was the most powerful Sith in history. Darth Bane wasn't powerful enough to extract himself from history, unfortunately.

Quote:
Three masters that weren't as strong as the PT Jedi you say? I remember something that mentioned ancient Force-users actually were more powerful than those from the present. That actually inverses your logic.
George Lucas has said that the Jedi in the PT are in their prime, in terms of combat.

Quote:
Palpatine didn't go up against four Council members, he took on one Council member, one master, and two knights.
No. Take a look at the Jedi Council. Kit Fisto, Agen Kolar, and Saesee Tiin were all Jedi Masters on the Council.

Quote:
I actually believe that due to the release issues, Master Vash was supposed to also be on Dantooine, but even three council members would have been more than Palpatine could handle. Given as he struggled against Windu, I would place my bets on Kreia. She killed three Council members with extreme ease, where Palpatine couldn't even beat Windu alone. (Yes there were three other Jedi, but they didn't aid Windu much)
Sidious lost in a lightsaber fight to Mace Windu, who had Shatterpoint and created the deadliest form of lightsaber combat, which had an edge over dark-siders. So that makes him a wimp? And the three Jedi didn't aid Windu much because Palpatine killed them within seconds.

Quote:
Nihilus actually became stronger as more powerful opponents got in his way. His hunger was his strength, so long as there were beings worth consuming. He would have died anyway, but not after being the last 'living' thing in the galaxy.
His hunger consumed him, and made him a mindless monster. He was a slave to his own abilities.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Lord of Hunger View Post
Mockery: Oh Master, this guy is the most uber 1337 dude ever because someone SAYS so without providing consistent evidence against the new facts that say otherwise.
What facts? Just because the ancient Sith were stronger than the old Sith, doesn't mean that the new Sith are weaker than the ancient Sith. You could probably attribute the degradation to the extinction of the Sith race, but after that, the Sith started to evolve via Bane.

Quote:
Hang onto the holy movies however much you want, doesn't change that a) the prequels are universally considered poorly made by anyone with good taste and b) there have been hundreds of new revelations about the Star Wars universe in general that make render this proclaimed superiority of Palpatine false.
PT movies, sucky or not, are still G-canon. G-canon overrules everything else.

Quote:
Uh...thought bomb? Then again, that was Revan's technique to begin with....
And it required several Sith to use. You can't use it alone.

Quote:
Please, despite their flaws any Master of that time could have kicked Windu's ***. Especially Kavar, the great Weapon Master who could have lead the Jedi in the Mandalorian Wars. And I'd like to Palpy try and drain Vrook, given that guy's iron discipline.
Prequel Jedi = Jedi prime in combat. Lucas said it in the TPM commentary, IIRC.

Quote:
Again, the all-important Force Storms that HE CAN'T EVEN CONTROL. It's like saying that someone is awesome because they can wildly fire a gun in random directions.
He can't fully control them, but they're not rampant upon creation. Like I said, it took Luke, Leia, and Anakin Solo's raw power to throw it off course. And the fact that Sidious had the power to even create a Force storm dwarfs any other feat.

Quote:
Lashowe could have taken the Sith Holocron of Tulak Hord and barely learned anything from it without even knowing it. Just because you have access to superior knowledge doesn't mean you'll fully understand it. Palpatine could have been granted all the holocrons of Malachor and he would never be able to learn Force Vampiricy without having a decent understanding of the Ancient Sith techniques themselves. That knowledge was limited to the Ancient/True Sith and a few select others.
Bane learned of the thought bomb from a Revan holocron. The Dark Empire Sourcebook quote is that he knew the most. Knowledge is knowledge.

Quote:
And what is your evidence for Yoda being so powerful, hm?
A quote from the RotS novel: "The truth: that he, the avatar of light, Supreme Master of the Jedi Order, the fiercest, most implacable, most devastatingly powerful foe the darkness had ever known..."

Other than that, his feats of Force surpass any given Jedi before him. If there are any demonstrations of power that match Yoda's, I can't name any.

Quote:
Convincing a whole bunch of weak-minded individuals and one Jedi Master to engage in a conflict the Galaxy is already heading towards. Yeah, great achievement in comparison to Revan, the guy who converted thousands to a completely different system of beliefs and not only nearly brought about the physical collapse of the Republic but also its spiritual collapse.
Using your own logic, the OJO was already flawed enough that turning Jedi wouldn't have been that hard. Sidious didn't turn Jedi because he saw them as threats, and he didn't need that. The only one he wanted to be succeeded by would be his apprentice.

Gob is offline   you may: quote & reply,
Old 08-15-2009, 05:39 PM   #91
Lord of Hunger
Hunger, The Lord Of
 
Lord of Hunger's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Korriban, Sith Empire
Posts: 1,022
Current Game: Shogun 2: Total War
Quote:
Originally Posted by TKA-001 View Post
Why does what makes sense to you mean that that is canon? Your only basis for that is taking a statement form George Lucas out of context into an illogical conclusion.
And what, pray tell, is so illogical about it?
Quote:
You have no evidence. Your argument of the Ancient Sith all being "Force Vampires" can be likened to the old fan theory that Darth Nihilus was actually a result of the Jedi Exile's soul splitting in half and the dark side of it taking root in some Jedi's corpse at Malachor: A bunch of random details taken out of context and wrapped together into a conclusion that falls flat on its face.
Watch the YouTube video I posted. That is the evidence right there, coupled with George Lucas' and in-universe statements about the nature of the Dark Side. Whether or not the Dark Side is an actual part of the Force or rather the evil within the universe that perverts the Force and warps it into a malicious entity is a different issue, but one I am also happy to debate (as it is a slightly modified view I have of the Unifying Force and Potentium theories).
Quote:
I don't see why Kreia would lie. Another thing I don't see is how the hell Kreia would know anything about the power level of ancient Sith and Jedi relative to Sith and Jedi during the First Jedi Purge. Kreia certainly wasn't alive back then. How would she even be able to compare them?
She extensively studied at the Coruscant Temple and Trayus Academy. Unlike Palpatine she is a historian and is far better trained to study the Ancient Sith.
Quote:
Even if the exaggerated accusations you make about Jedi arrogance and Jedi evil are all true, they would not make them weaker in the Force or combat.
Actually it does. The strength of Jedi and Sith is in their respective moral Force entities (Light and Dark Side). When the Jedi move towards the Dark Side they loose the integrity of their Light Side abilities and it takes a long time for someone who has studied the Light Side to adjust the Dark Side and visa versa. The fact that alignment affects ease with alignment based abilities is not just a game mechanic.

The Jedi thoroughly embraced a deep hatred of the Sith and their own arrogance, causing their abilities to weaken over time. Coupled with how many techniques were lost with the deaths of the Great Sith War era Masters and the Ossus Libraries, the Jedi Order has been in a steady decline. By seeking out other Force Sensitive Orders and embracing alternative ideas, the members of the NJO restored much of the lost knowledge of the Force.
Quote:
Oh. So I guess Anakin Skywalker's skill with machines and piloting vehicles, crime-investigation proficiency of the likes of Obi-Wan Kenobi and Jax Pavan, and the standard diplomacy skills that Jedi were so favored by the Republic government for don't count as "real-life" skills, then?
This was thanks to the Jedi Exile and the teachings of Kreia. That, and Anakin was just naturally good with machines. But the other forms of decline still remained.
Quote:
I don't see much evidence of brilliant proficiency of the Massassi or above any other type of soldier (it might or might not be worth mentioning that they were all enslaved single-handedly by one Sith, Exar Kun), or of the Kissai above any other type of sufficiently-experience Force-user.
It's more of the fact that the Sith species was naturally Force Sensitive, if only a little. If coupled with Force Vampiricy, the Ancient Sith Lords could feed upon the excess radiating energies of their armies to fuel such abilities as Battle Mediation without a sweat. Such are the Ancient Sith too be feared, and fortunately for the people of TOR era, most of the Sith of that time are normal people recruited by the last few True Sith.
Quote:
So what? So could Palpatine.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Darth_Yuthura
No, I think it was meant that Kreia could make herself invisible. Palpatine was like a Purloined letter.
QTF
Quote:
Actually, yes. Palpatine had telepathic connections to a number of (or all, not sure on how many) his Emperor's Hands, which he could use to issue orders, among other things. The most well-known example, of course, is Mara Jade. Palpatine also temporarily transferred his spirit into the body of Jeng Droga, another Emperor's Hand.
Point conceded.
Quote:
That's ****ing stupid. I refuse to believe that that is possible. There is no actual evidence given in TSL for that, besides.
Think Force Zombie.
Quote:
More handwaving. This does not actually explain your hypothesis at all. Furthermore, what special techniques did Palpatine use that he learned from before? More importantly, why does that make him any weaker?
I bring it up because Bane is Palpatine's oldest predicessor in that Order. Palpatine would be slightly greater due to the amount of other techniques learned, but it would be a tough match, and other teammates could move in to finish Palpy off.
Quote:
You can't know that for sure. I freely admit that it is possible that Nihilus' attention is more easily aroused by the presence of multiple powerful Force-users, but that is only conjecture. We have only one event known where Nihilus directs his drainage power toward an individual, and in that case, the Exile had to be standing within spitting distance of Nihilus before the Dark Lord even noticed her/his presence. Not enough of Nihilus has been seen in order to determine exactly how his power works.
Again, the Exile is a Force Blackhole in relation to Nihilus. She is more intriguing than appetizing. She in fact is also a mirror to Nihilus, so he would have probably preferred to study her if possible. However, provocation and built up hunger eventually got the best of him.
Quote:
If there was no flesh, then how do you explain Nihilus being killed by the Exile's lightsaber if there was no flesh to cut and no vital organs to sever?
The armor. A lightsaber can damage the structural integrity of the armor, causing it to be destroyed and thus Nihilus' spirit released.
Quote:
More exaggeration about how wimpy the Jedi Order supposedly was. Palpatine spend decades manipulating himself into becoming the head of state of the Republic by means which as far as everyone else knew was legitimate. He staged galactic crises and conflicts to solidify his power, evaded detection from the Jedi this whole time, turned one of the Jedi Order's most powerful Jedi into his apprentice... Why am I typing this paragraph? We both know Palpatine's achievements.
Exaggerated achievements. For one thing, TFU unfortunately made it worse by harping upon that era when it was explored enough. They had to make yet another "uber 1337" Force User when Starkiller isn't really that great. The game mechanics make Palpatine look more powerful than he is. There is also more footage of Palpatine than there is of the Ancient Sith or the Triumvirate, but while it makes Palpy look more powerful and badass, a critical eye can see it is all hype.
Quote:
So what? It never would have gotten there if he hadn't declared the Empire himself. And while the Republic was corrupt by the time of The Phantom Menace, I think it is quite a stretch to say that it would have eventually turned out as bad as the Empire without Palpy's influence.
If it wasn't Palpatine it would have been someone else.
Quote:
So you're saying that the Ancient Sith Lords were immune to being thrown down neigh-bottomless pits.
Probably. The Ancient Sith were indeed geniuses to have invented Sith Sorcery. I doubt they would have let hubris get the best of them THAT easily.
Quote:
He was defeated because they cut off his connection to the dark side, not because they were superior to him in Force strength.
It would have taken a lot of strength to disrupt such a connection.
Quote:
What's that supposed to mean? Should Palpatine be running around with his lightsaber charging at rebel installations and bases in the Outer Rim all the time?
Yes. Don't trust your inferiors to mess up for you. Do your own bloody work. Revan and Malak for example were often on the front lines. Sion killed his opponents himself.
Quote:
Whether you like it or not, Kit Fisto, Agen Kolar, Saesee Tiin, and Mace Windu have all been repeatedly cited as masters in their areas of lightsaber combat, and your argument that they are significantly weaker than previous generations of Jedi does not hold up.
As Darth_Yuthura has pointed out, they are nothing special.
Quote:
Granted, without Vader's help in killing key Jedi Masters, the fight would have been more difficult, but it only would have meant some heavier clone trooper casualties, and to a galaxy-spanning Empire, the lives of a few thousands clone troopers are nothing. As we see in Attack of the Clones, even large groups of Force users can be brought down if you spam them with foot soldiers enough. Besides, even if they did defeat the entire infantry force sent at the temple, the Republic army would just use a Star Destroyer to level the temple from low orbit. Given the resources at the Republic's disposal, there was no possible way to lose Operation Knightfall unless they gave up.
Do you think that they would have just stayed there if they didn't have to fight Anakin? They would have more likely taken over one of those Star Destroyers you mentioned.
Quote:
Because Palpatine loves power. He wants the most powerful Empire, the most powerful personal strength in the Force, and therefore the most powerful apprentice available.
As his love of power made him pride, thus more susceptible to backstabbing and the like. Nihilus had no pride, only hunger. Sion had no pride, only pain. Traya had little pride, only a desire to destroy ideologies. Revan? I doubt it as the guy was a strategist...which makes him inherently cool headed. Malak? Yes, just like Palpatine. Bane? A little. The Ancient Sith? Balanced by their cunning.
Quote:
Wookieepedia says that the Empire was more decentralized, so it was. That statement isn't sourced. More to the point, how is the above information indicative of decentralized power?
Because there was little more than fragile loyalty to Palpatine that kept the Empire together. Each Moff had his own little kingdom and other Moff with their kingdoms to contend with. And they are all very ambitious individuals.
Quote:
My apologies. Our debate would be more enjoyable without my using provocative language.
Indeed.
Quote:
Hair-splitting. There's no way that a superweapon arms race would start within the Empire without the Emperor's knowledge.
As DY said, Maw Installation?
Quote:
Why would such a situation arise in the first place? Thrawn didn't have any plans to overthrow the Emperor. His allegiance is to the Empire, and therefore the ruler of the Empire, and therefore Palpatine. The only reason he tried to take control during the Thrawn Trilogy was because there was no Emperor.
Give the guy time and he'll get to the top of the Admirality chain. Then whatever ambition he has will take over, as well as the desire to triumph over someone he admires. He will also desire to remove the restrictions on non-humans. They guy is not a sap.
Quote:
The apprentice's "fight" with Palpatine was a brief trading of Force-related attacks until Palpatine ended up getting stunned. The Emperor was obviously bull****ting the apprentice about how weak he supposedly was. Even in the game's alternate ending, the apprentice is no match for the Emperor.
See DY's argument. It is mine too here as well.
Quote:
Again, this idea that the Empire would have formed on its own is simply a theory based on exaggerated accusations of Galactic Republic corruption.
It is impossible to exaggerate the Republic's corruption.
Quote:
No other Sith has killed master Jedi swordsman in less time than it takes to blow one's nose.
Nihilus slaughtered a planet of Force Sensitives with mere words.
Quote:
I thought Sion was invincible. Incidentally, since we've apparently established that Sion can instantly reattach his severed limbs back onto his body, what would happen if you blasted him with a Star Destroyer's heavy guns?
That's a possibility, but I doubt he would wait for it to happen. Especially since like with the Harbinger his Assassins would have already killed anyone on that SD.
Quote:
As for Nihilus, since he died from being killed and was in danger of starving to death anyway... No, he wasn't immortal.
Pretty damn close though.
Quote:
Who?
What, you think he invented that technique?
Quote:
Palpatine did all of those things just as well. Why does the fact that he isn't the first or only person to do these things make it less impressive?
Uh no. Palpatine played on existing loyalites, not forging new ones.
Quote:
A less-than-clean aim, to be sure (indeed, the first thing the KotOR-era Jedi do that I agree seems low for them), but I believe that in this case, preserving the "power" of the Jedi Masters over their brash, younger ranks like Revan and Malak would have served a greater good by preventing or stalling their rebellion. That said, I would sincerely appreciate it if we could all keep the matter of First Jedi Order morality or lack thereof out of this debate, because I've already debated it exhaustively with Lord of Hunger and would prefer not to return to previously-trodden ground.
...
Quote:
To be fair, I don't see much reason to believe the Jedi Civil War-era Jedi were weaker than those of later eras.
Again, many higher techniques were lost with the Great Sith War Masters and Ossus.
Quote:
So Palpatine was mentally incapable of understanding these Ancient techniques? Why? Furthermore, what proof do you have that he was incapable?
For one thing, the resources are increasingly rare over time. Traya, Sion, and Nihilus could do it because they had Malachor, its facilities intact.
Quote:
Revan did the mass-conversion by corrupting the Jedi in the wars and then pushing them over the edge with Malachor. Any master manipulator could have done that, provided they know about Force wounds (and given Revan seems to have known about them without anyone telling him, I don't see why Palpatine couldn't).
Then why didn't Palpatine do so, hmmmm? There were plenty of wounds from the Clone Wars and Galactic Civil War to work with.
Quote:
What is this spiritual collapse which you speak of? And what sources can you cite in regards to how the Republic was practically already the Empire before Palpatine stepped in?
I am not going to repeat myself yet again...sorry.


As of 3/14/10, TSL is restored. The Sith Lords Restored Content Modification by Stoney and Zbyl has been finished and can be downloaded here.

Lord of Hunger is offline   you may: quote & reply,
Old 08-15-2009, 11:10 PM   #92
Darth_Yuthura
Banned
 
Status: Banned
Join Date: May 2008
Location: Vienna
Posts: 1,585
Current Game: KOTOR III
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gob View Post
George Lucas has said that the Jedi in the PT are in their prime, in terms of combat.
Wrong context. He explicitly explained why Vader and Luke fighting were not as impressive as the pre trilogy being it was a cripple, a youth, and an old man in the original trilogy vs. Jedi who were at their prime.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Gob View Post
Sidious lost in a lightsaber fight to Mace Windu, who had Shatterpoint and created the deadliest form of lightsaber combat, which had an edge over dark-siders. So that makes him a wimp? And the three Jedi didn't aid Windu much because Palpatine killed them within seconds.
That's right and then Mace beat Palpatine's ass with his own Force lightning.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Gob View Post
What facts? Just because the ancient Sith were stronger than the old Sith, doesn't mean that the new Sith are weaker than the ancient Sith. You could probably attribute the degradation to the extinction of the Sith race, but after that, the Sith started to evolve via Bane.
Until Palpatine stepped in and violated the code by killing his master before surpassing him and then dropping everything of the rule of two in his unquenchable lust for power. That was what brought about his demise.

I would be more inclined to say Darth Plagueous was the peak of the Sith and that Palpatine never reached his level, let alone exceeded him.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Gob View Post
Prequel Jedi = Jedi prime in combat. Lucas said it in the TPM commentary, IIRC.
That argument = wrong context.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Gob View Post
Bane learned of the thought bomb from a Revan holocron. The Dark Empire Sourcebook quote is that he knew the most. Knowledge is knowledge.
Yeah, but it's not like Bane learned everything that Revan knew from that holocron. Did Revan put everything he knew on that holocron?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Gob View Post
A quote from the RotS novel: "The truth: that he, the avatar of light, Supreme Master of the Jedi Order, the fiercest, most implacable, most devastatingly powerful foe the darkness had ever known..."

Other than that, his feats of Force surpass any given Jedi before him. If there are any demonstrations of power that match Yoda's, I can't name any.
Exar Kunn. Revan. Anakin. Bane. These are all guesses, but take into consideration that your conclusion is about as solid as these, who've beaten Sidious or were regarded so highly in what they were capable of.

Windu can at least take credit for kicking Palpatine's ass one-on-one. Marek, who also eliminated Vader as well, proved his might against Palpatine.

Last edited by Darth_Yuthura; 08-15-2009 at 11:30 PM.
Darth_Yuthura is offline   you may: quote & reply,
Old 08-16-2009, 11:13 AM   #93
TKA-001
I sneer at thee.
 
TKA-001's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2005
Posts: 1,535
Forum Veteran 
Quote:
And what, pray tell, is so illogical about it?
Can you perhaps summarize this theory in as few words as possible, like in one paragraph or something? I'm having trouble piecing it together from all of these posts.

Quote:
Exaggerated achievements. For one thing, TFU unfortunately made it worse by harping upon that era when it was explored enough. They had to make yet another "uber 1337" Force User when Starkiller isn't really that great. The game mechanics make Palpatine look more powerful than he is. There is also more footage of Palpatine than there is of the Ancient Sith or the Triumvirate, but while it makes Palpy look more powerful and badass, a critical eye can see it is all hype.
What happens in The Force Unleashed is as fully canon as anything else, whether you like it or not.

"Game mechanics make Palpatine look more powerful"? I really don't know what you're referring to. More to the point, your statement that "a critical eye can see it is all hype" is really just a cover for the fact that you don't actually have anything to base your argument on, so you fall back on the insistence that you only need a "critical eye" to see it... Whatever it is, since you can't actually explain it.

Quote:
When the Jedi move towards the Dark Side they loose the integrity of their Light Side abilities and it takes a long time for someone who has studied the Light Side to adjust the Dark Side and visa versa. The fact that alignment affects ease with alignment based abilities is not just a game mechanic.
Conjecture, conjecture, conjecture, based on a game mechanic which is not just a game mechanic because you say so.

Quote:
The armor. A lightsaber can damage the structural integrity of the armor, causing it to be destroyed and thus Nihilus' spirit released.
...so what happened? Did the Exile's lightsaber hit a "vital organ" part of the armor? Did the armor totally disintegrate? If it broke apart, why would Nihilus' soul (or whatever) be released instead of staying in the pieces? If the armor disintegrated totally, wouldn't that kill his spirit?

Quote:
Coupled with how many techniques were lost with the deaths of the Great Sith War era Masters and the Ossus Libraries
...techniques which you either cannot name or cannot prove were ever lost in the first place.

Quote:
Katarr. Master Zhar... Master Vandar... and a lot of other Jedi.
Katarr was the case of Nihilus against an entire planet's worth of Force-sensitives, which is not close to the sort of situation which is supposedly the focus of this thread.

Quote:
I only wish Atris were there as well.
Whatever.

Quote:
If Anakin had simply not selfishly killed Windu, Order 66 wouldn't have been given and the original trilogy wouldn't have happened.
So you buy the idea that Palpatine was totally helpless against Mace even though he went ape**** on him with lightning as soon as he was distracted? Do you propose that Palpatine was physically incapable of blasting Mace with more lightning as he raised his lightsaber until Anakin cut his hand off?

Quote:
The Maw installation comes to mind.
A secret weapon research facility a superweapon-fueled civil war does not make.

Quote:
Oh is this that self-fulfilling argument again? Palpatine wasn't defeated by Windu because he was letting himself almost be killed so that Anakin would save him. He just thought it would be great to toy around with Starkiller and almost let himself get killed again. Is that what you're saying?
What I'm saying is that there is no reason to believe Palpatine was in any serious danger from Vader's former apprentice. And yes, there is indeed a good chance that Palpatine threw the fight with Mace (though that he threw the fight with the apprentice is obvious).

Quote:
That's not Palpatine's style. He would not engage those Master swordsman if he could just as easily wipe them out with the Force. Clearly he resorted to a lightsaber because that was his only way of defeating those Jedi.
...and your evidence for this is... What? Name a Jedi or Sith who does not fight other Jedi and Sith with a lightsaber.

Quote:
No, it was because Windu could not only defend himself against, but redirect Palpatine's lightning against him. Yoda, Starkiller, and Windu could all do that.
Not that it did them any good (though I don't remember any point at which Vader's apprentice redirected Palpatine's lightning back at him, in the game or in the novel).

Quote:
What, you think he invented that technique?
Nobody? I thought not. I don't see any reason to believe he didn't, since he wrote a freaking book about it, and of course, he's the only one who has ever used it. Feel free to name someone else who has conjured Force storms of the kind Palpatine used.

Quote:
Uh no. Palpatine played on existing loyalites, not forging new ones.
So Anakin was loyal to Palpatine before he started building trust for ten years? The clone army was loyal to him before he had it created? The Republic was loyal to him before he worked his way to the office of the Supreme Chancellor? Almost the entire Senate cheered him on when he declared the Empire solely because they were all corrupt bastards who wanted an Empire, instead of because they wanted a well-liked, "honest", great leader to rally around? (If the Republic was so horrible, why did anyone want to form an Alliance to Restore the Republic?) The military was loyal to the Emperor before Palpatine became Emperor?

Quote:
Yes. Don't trust your inferiors to mess up for you. Do your own bloody work. Revan and Malak for example were often on the front lines. Sion killed his opponents himself.
And why is doing everything yourself so admirable when it really doesn't make a difference who does it? Besides, Palpatine has better things to do than waste time leading troops against insurrections and rebellions when there is no need to dirty his own hands; If any event is big enough to catch his notice, then he will deal with it behind the scenes. For one thing, he has to keep up the publicity of being the sick old man who is being increasingly isolated from the Empire (one of the reasons he did this was to prevent the Empire's atrocities from being connected to him personally, rather than his underlings). For another, if he wasted his time publicly running the Empire on its day-to-day businesses (a menial task which he assigned to Grand Vizier Sate Pestage and the Ruling Council), he wouldn't have time to expand his dark side knowledge and the like.

Quote:
As Darth_Yuthura has pointed out, they are nothing special.
...by saying so, ignoring what is stated and demonstrated in-universe. Kit Fisto almost beat General Grievous in a duel, for example.

Quote:
They would have more likely taken over one of those Star Destroyers you mentioned.
..how, exactly? The Jedi Temple doesn't have a fleet protecting it. How would they be able to board a Star Destroyer in the first place if they're already under siege from the ground and the air? Incidentally, the Episode III Video Game actually did have several Venator-class Star Destroyers circling the Temple during the attack, along with Gunships practically carpet-bombing the area.

Quote:
It is impossible to exaggerate the Republic's corruption.
Give me some sources and examples, or don't bother. You can't just tell me that Core World supremacy and anti-alien racism was rampant throughout the Republic and everyone was corrupt. You have to actually show me that the Republic would turn into an Empire on its own.

Quote:
If it wasn't Palpatine it would have been someone else.
Like who? Name a person. Name a source. Name something, name anything that is actually based in canon instead of speculation.

Quote:
Because there was little more than fragile loyalty to Palpatine that kept the Empire together. Each Moff had his own little kingdom and other Moff with their kingdoms to contend with. And they are all very ambitious individuals.
And the evidence you have for this "fragile loyalty" being the "only thing" keeping the Empire together is what? Furthermore, why does people in positions of power being ambitious mean that most or all of them will want to kill the Emperor (the common soldiers of the military are indoctrinated to be fanatically loyal to the Emperor [Visual Dictionary])? And if this "inevitable anarchy civil war" stuff is true, why did it never even begin to happen until after Palpatine was dead? (It might also be worth mentioning that most of the Empire fell back into line almost immediately after he returned ten years after Yavin.)

Quote:
Give the guy time and he'll get to the top of the Admirality chain.
Thrawn was actually at the top of the Admirality chain before Endor and he had no plans of killing the Emperor.

Quote:
That's a possibility, but I doubt he would wait for it to happen. Especially since like with the Harbinger his Assassins would have already killed anyone on that SD.
You are dodging the question. What would happen if Sion was hit by a capital ship's heavy turbolasers?

Quote:
I am not going to repeat myself yet again...sorry.
In other words... No, you don't have any sources.

Quote:
Again, many higher techniques were lost with the Great Sith War Masters and Ossus.
Such as... And don't tell me that techniques were lost just because they're only seen in one source. If you can only theorize that they were lost, instead of prove it, then don't bother.

Quote:
Then why didn't Palpatine do so, hmmmm? There were plenty of wounds from the Clone Wars and Galactic Civil War to work with.
Why did he need to? He didn't want an army of Dark Jedi like Revan wanted; A technological army to secure the dark side utopia he eventually wanted to create (Dark Empire sourcebook) was all that he needed.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Darth_Yuthura View Post
Wrong context. He explicitly explained why Vader and Luke fighting were not as impressive as the pre trilogy being it was a cripple, a youth, and an old man in the original trilogy vs. Jedi who were at their prime.
That's not how Lucas explained "superior" swordsmanship and power. It's how he explained the fights being more spectacular from the perspective of one viewing the movie. Furthermore, George Lucas' word is not canon. What he does and places explicitly into the canon is canon. Nothing else. If Lucas said that Darth Vader's lightsaber in Episode VI was blue instead of red without releasing a newer edition or whatever, would he be right?

Quote:
That's right and then Mace beat Palpatine's ass with his own Force lightning.
Mace Windu's strength was visibly being worn down by the Chancellor's lightning barrage, and Palpatine's being so weak that he needs Anakin or else the evil Jedi will murder him was obviously a ruse. Then there's the possibility that he threw the fight with Mace.

Quote:
Until Palpatine stepped in and violated the code by killing his master before surpassing him and then dropping everything of the rule of two in his unquenchable lust for power. That was what brought about his demise.
First of all, there is no canonical reason whatsoever to suggest that Sidious did not surpass his master by the time he murdered him in his sleep. It's entirely possible that he was stronger or whatever. Second, what "code" are you talking about? How was it a "violation" for Sidious to kill Darth Plagueis at whatever time he chose to?

Quote:
I would be more inclined to say Darth Plagueous was the peak of the Sith and that Palpatine never reached his level, let alone exceeded him.
...not that you have any actual evidence for this, since our canonical knowledge of Plagueis' actual abilities and strengths is minimal.

Quote:
Marek, who also eliminated Vader as well, proved his might against Palpatine.
"Proved his might?" He Force-pushed the Emperor a few times and then got his ass blown up by Palpatine's bitch-slap lightning. He never stood a chance.


"There is something going on in time and space, and beyond time and space, which, whether we like it or not, spells duty." -Winston Churchill

"For of all sad words of tongue or pen, The saddest are these: 'It might have been!'" -John Whittier

"Apathy is death." -Kreia

Last edited by TKA-001; 08-16-2009 at 12:12 PM.
TKA-001 is offline   you may: quote & reply,
Old 08-16-2009, 03:07 PM   #94
Darth_Yuthura
Banned
 
Status: Banned
Join Date: May 2008
Location: Vienna
Posts: 1,585
Current Game: KOTOR III
Quote:
Originally Posted by TKA-001 View Post
So you buy the idea that Palpatine was totally helpless against Mace even though he went ape**** on him with lightning as soon as he was distracted? Do you propose that Palpatine was physically incapable of blasting Mace with more lightning as he raised his lightsaber until Anakin cut his hand off?
Yes. No.

Palpatine could have continued blasting Mace, but why would he have wanted to? If you didn't plunge your hand into boiling water, did that mean you weren't capable of doing it? Palpatine obviously stopped blasting Mace because Mace was turning it back on him. Only when Mace lost his lightsaber did he start blasting him again.

Quote:
Originally Posted by TKA-001 View Post
A secret weapon research facility a superweapon-fueled civil war does not make.
???

Do you mean a secret superweapon facility that built the Sun Crusher?

Quote:
Originally Posted by TKA-001 View Post

What I'm saying is that there is no reason to believe Palpatine was in any serious danger from Vader's former apprentice. And yes, there is indeed a good chance that Palpatine threw the fight with Mace (though that he threw the fight with the apprentice is obvious).
I don't see the logic, so please explain. Don't say it's clear because that implies you're obviously right with or without any reason.

And to explain why I don't see it as obvious, there is flawed logic in both cases. First is that Skywalker wasn't present until at the very end of the fight. As Skywalker wasn't even expected to be there when the fight broke out, Palpatine had no motive to let himself be defeated. If he were present before it started, then that argument might stand.

There also was a lot of reason to assume he was in danger from Starkiller. Before Kota stopped him, the Emperor was just one lightsaber stroke away from death. The Emperor was beaten by a better opponent.

Quote:
Originally Posted by TKA-001 View Post
...and your evidence for this is... What? Name a Jedi or Sith who does not fight other Jedi and Sith with a lightsaber.
Kreia.

Quote:
Originally Posted by TKA-001 View Post
Not that it did them any good (though I don't remember any point at which Vader's apprentice redirected Palpatine's lightning back at him, in the game or in the novel).
Play the game. I can't speak for the novel, but the apprentice did redirect the lightning back with the saber in the game. Then he did it without a saber in the cutscene. The only reason that he died was because his intent wasn't to beat Palpatine, but to keep the senators from being killed.

Quote:
Originally Posted by TKA-001 View Post
That's not how Lucas explained "superior" swordsmanship and power. It's how he explained the fights being more spectacular from the perspective of one viewing the movie. Furthermore, George Lucas' word is not canon. What he does and places explicitly into the canon is canon. Nothing else. If Lucas said that Darth Vader's lightsaber in Episode VI was blue instead of red without releasing a newer edition or whatever, would he be right?
Are you talking about the same thing? I suppose that you do prove a point that nothing Lucas says in an interview is cannon, so his quote 'Jedi in their Prime' doesn't mean the PT Jedi were the most powerful ever.

Quote:
Originally Posted by TKA-001 View Post
Mace Windu's strength was visibly being worn down by the Chancellor's lightning barrage, and Palpatine's being so weak that he needs Anakin or else the evil Jedi will murder him was obviously a ruse. Then there's the possibility that he threw the fight with Mace.
Again the use of the word 'obvious.' I could just as easily say that Palpatine obviously wasn't able to beat Windu, which was why he would have died if Anakin didn't attack Mace.

Quote:
Originally Posted by TKA-001 View Post
First of all, there is no canonical reason whatsoever to suggest that Sidious did not surpass his master by the time he murdered him in his sleep. It's entirely possible that he was stronger or whatever. Second, what "code" are you talking about? How was it a "violation" for Sidious to kill Darth Plagueis at whatever time he chose to?
Yes there is. Palpatine figured out how to clone himself after death. He was powerful, but there were many shortfalls in which his master could have accomplished to a greater degree. Anakin was supposed to be the 'perfect Jedi' in which was supposed to replace Palpatine as his apprentice. Palpatine could never pull off something like that, considering how much effort he went to for Luke after Vader was crippled.

Quote:
Originally Posted by TKA-001 View Post
...not that you have any actual evidence for this, since our canonical knowledge of Plagueis' actual abilities and strengths is minimal.
You're right. Minimal evidence. Palpatine never reached the extent to which he could replicate the supposed-abilities that Plagueis achieved in his lifetime. His cloning technique did save him when Plagueis was killed altogether, but he could never perform the kind of feat as creating a 'perfect' Force-entity as Anakin.

Quote:
Originally Posted by TKA-001 View Post
"Proved his might?" He Force-pushed the Emperor a few times and then got his ass blown up by Palpatine's bitch-slap lightning. He never stood a chance.
That's a joke right? Starkiller beat the Emperor and nearly executed him, but that stupid Kota interfered. In so doing, the situation became unstable and Starkiller sacrificed himself to ensure the Senators could escape. The 'blowing up' part was Starkiller's doing.
Darth_Yuthura is offline   you may: quote & reply,
Old 08-16-2009, 05:04 PM   #95
Gob
Rookie
 
Gob's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: Super Awesome Land
Posts: 166
Quote:
Originally Posted by Darth_Yuthura View Post
Yes. No.

Palpatine could have continued blasting Mace, but why would he have wanted to? If you didn't plunge your hand into boiling water, did that mean you weren't capable of doing it? Palpatine obviously stopped blasting Mace because Mace was turning it back on him. Only when Mace lost his lightsaber did he start blasting him again.
Palpatine's power was being fueled by his own pain, so he could go as long as he wanted. He stopped blasting Mace to look helpless in front of Anakin.

Quote:
I don't see the logic, so please explain. Don't say it's clear because that implies you're obviously right with or without any reason.

And to explain why I don't see it as obvious, there is flawed logic in both cases. First is that Skywalker wasn't present until at the very end of the fight. As Skywalker wasn't even expected to be there when the fight broke out, Palpatine had no motive to let himself be defeated. If he were present before it started, then that argument might stand.

There also was a lot of reason to assume he was in danger from Starkiller. Before Kota stopped him, the Emperor was just one lightsaber stroke away from death. The Emperor was beaten by a better opponent.
No. He threw the fight against Marek in order to get him to turn back to the dark side. It's highly probable that Galen Marek's full potential would be stronger than Palpatine, but in TFU, he wasn't. You can see this when Galen is absorbing Palpatine's lightning. In order to even hold Palpatine off, he had to release all of his Force energy, which killed him. And that only pushed Palpatine away for a moment.

However, you are right that Sidious probably didn't throw the fight against Mace. He did stop going all out once Anakin showed up, though.

Quote:
Kreia.
Your argument seems to be that Palpatine's skill with a lightsaber is greater than his skill with the Force. If this was true, he would've lost to Yoda, who is obviously Mace's superior in the Force. And Kreia has done absolutely nothing to prove her skill with a lightsaber. I'm not saying she's a total weakling, but the only thing she has going for her is her Force drain, which isn't necessarily unstoppable.

Quote:
Are you talking about the same thing? I suppose that you do prove a point that nothing Lucas says in an interview is cannon, so his quote 'Jedi in their Prime' doesn't mean the PT Jedi were the most powerful ever.
Actually, is word is canon, unless it conflicts with the movie. At that point, I'm not sure. But if he says that the PT Jedi are the strongest, then it's canon, since it doesn't say otherwise in the movies.

Quote:
Again the use of the word 'obvious.' I could just as easily say that Palpatine obviously wasn't able to beat Windu, which was why he would have died if Anakin didn't attack Mace.
Do you have proof of this? Mace was barely holding back Palpatine's lightning. He was using his Vaapad to channel the lightning back at Palpatine, and since Vaapad is a Force-fed form, his defense may have very well be broken. This is speculation, but so was your statement.

Quote:
Yes there is. Palpatine figured out how to clone himself after death. He was powerful, but there were many shortfalls in which his master could have accomplished to a greater degree. Anakin was supposed to be the 'perfect Jedi' in which was supposed to replace Palpatine as his apprentice. Palpatine could never pull off something like that, considering how much effort he went to for Luke after Vader was crippled.
I'm not sure what you're saying here. Palpatine could never pull off training Anakin? Or Palpatine could never pull off being the perfect Jedi?

Quote:
You're right. Minimal evidence. Palpatine never reached the extent to which he could replicate the supposed-abilities that Plagueis achieved in his lifetime. His cloning technique did save him when Plagueis was killed altogether, but he could never perform the kind of feat as creating a 'perfect' Force-entity as Anakin.
There's no proof that Plagueis created Anakin. It's possible, but there's nothing to confirm it. Palpatine didn't continue pursuing the creation of life, as far as I know.

Quote:
That's a joke right? Starkiller beat the Emperor and nearly executed him, but that stupid Kota interfered. In so doing, the situation became unstable and Starkiller sacrificed himself to ensure the Senators could escape. The 'blowing up' part was Starkiller's doing.
Yes, it was Starkiller releasing all of his Force energy at once. It resulted in his own death, and didn't do any serious damage to Palpatine. If he had the ability to just overpower Palpatine without killing himself, he would have. But he didn't. Self-sacrifice was the only way out of the situation.

Gob is offline   you may: quote & reply,
Old 08-16-2009, 05:23 PM   #96
Giant Graffiti
Custom User Title
 
Giant Graffiti's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 828
Quote:
Originally Posted by Darth_Yuthura View Post
Kreia.
Huh?

Show spoiler
Giant Graffiti is offline   you may: quote & reply,
Old 08-16-2009, 06:30 PM   #97
Darth_Yuthura
Banned
 
Status: Banned
Join Date: May 2008
Location: Vienna
Posts: 1,585
Current Game: KOTOR III
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gιygαs View Post
Huh?
Yeah, she killed three masters just with the wave of her hand.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Gob View Post
Palpatine's power was being fueled by his own pain, so he could go as long as he wanted. He stopped blasting Mace to look helpless in front of Anakin.
Or Mace genuinely was killing Palpatine. His Force power may have been intensifying, but his flesh wasn't enduring so well.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Gob View Post
No. He threw the fight against Marek in order to get him to turn back to the dark side. It's highly probable that Galen Marek's full potential would be stronger than Palpatine, but in TFU, he wasn't. You can see this when Galen is absorbing Palpatine's lightning. In order to even hold Palpatine off, he had to release all of his Force energy, which killed him. And that only pushed Palpatine away for a moment.
Correction: Marek beat his ass and would have killed Palpatine if Koto hadn't intervened. Then Palpatine took advantage of his mercy and put him in an unexpected predicament. Had Marek stuck down Palpatine, he would have eliminated the Sith once and for all.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Gob View Post
However, you are right that Sidious probably didn't throw the fight against Mace. He did stop going all out once Anakin showed up, though.
Once his lightsaber was gone. Anakin showed up just as he was left defenseless, so it could be one way or another, pending on what you believe.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Gob View Post
Actually, is word is canon, unless it conflicts with the movie. At that point, I'm not sure. But if he says that the PT Jedi are the strongest, then it's canon, since it doesn't say otherwise in the movies.
Alright, I would accept that. So if you would ask Mr. Lucas that question specifically so he could answer it directly, I will accept his answer. Since he hadn't said that PT were the strongest of all Jedi and all Sith of all time, then it's not canon. And even if it were, why would the next generation of Jedi and Sith be less powerful than the generation before it?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Gob View Post
Do you have proof of this? Mace was barely holding back Palpatine's lightning. He was using his Vaapad to channel the lightning back at Palpatine, and since Vaapad is a Force-fed form, his defense may have very well be broken. This is speculation, but so was your statement.
The proof was that Palpatine was vulnerable and Mace would have killed him if not for Anakin. Mace was in a lot better condition being exhausted than Palpatine was almost being dead... until Anakin stepped in. All that the 'Emperor threw the fight' can never be more than speculation.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Gob View Post
I'm not sure what you're saying here. Palpatine could never pull off training Anakin? Or Palpatine could never pull off being the perfect Jedi?
If Palpatine wanted a servant to replace Vader so greatly, then why didn't he just create one instead of investing all those resources into scouring the galaxy for Luke?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Gob View Post
Yes, it was Starkiller releasing all of his Force energy at once. It resulted in his own death, and didn't do any serious damage to Palpatine. If he had the ability to just overpower Palpatine without killing himself, he would have. But he didn't. Self-sacrifice was the only way out of the situation.
Well don't forget that Starkiller had the Emperor at his mercy and very well could have disposed of him. Killing him would have been the more favorable way out, but that was lost when Palpatine went for Kota and the Senators.

------

And let's not lose perspective on this topic.

An F-22 can simultaneously engage five F-15's and still expect victory, but that doesn't exactly mean that it's better than those five fighters. An F-22 certainly cannot engage 20 Mig-29's, but those five F-15's could. They likely wouldn't be able to wipe them all out, but they would do better fighting at a four to one disadvantage than an F-22 going twenty to one.

Just because a character could beat another doesn't exactly mean they are better in all other regards. Malak betrayed his master, but he was certainly an imp compared to Revan's power and knowledge. Windu could wipe out Palpatine, but I wouldn't say he could do all the warmongering of which he did.

Last edited by Darth_Yuthura; 08-16-2009 at 09:16 PM.
Darth_Yuthura is offline   you may: quote & reply,
Old 08-16-2009, 08:35 PM   #98
Ping
Elementary.
 
Ping's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: Pennsylvania
Posts: 784
Roleplayer 
Quote:
Yeah, she killed three masters just with the wave of her hand.
I think what he meant was someone who never, ever used a lightsaber.


"There is no such thing as coincidence, only inevitability" - xxxHoLiC

"Justice? But I don't serve justice, Watson, I serve the truth." - Sherlock Holmes
Ping is offline   you may: quote & reply,
Old 08-17-2009, 06:50 PM   #99
Lord of Hunger
Hunger, The Lord Of
 
Lord of Hunger's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Korriban, Sith Empire
Posts: 1,022
Current Game: Shogun 2: Total War
While I personally don't feel like having to clarify and explain every single aspect of the Star Wars universe in order to continue this debate, I would like to clarify that Palpatine is not the first user of Force Storm or inventor or anything like that:

Quote:
Originally Posted by Wookiepedia
Force Storm

Force Storm was a Force lightning variant. The user would raise his palm upward and would create, through the Force, an explosion of electrical energy directed at all foes in the vicinity. It was used by both the Sith and Dark Jedi during the Jedi Civil War. It also appeared as a tornado of energy which created a great disturbance in the Force. Jedi could also join together to create a Force storm, though its use was frowned upon by more orthodox Jedi.

Unlike the Force lightning, Force Storm was not limited to attacking enemies in one direction, as it affected all foes within a certain radius from the user. Revan and the Jedi Exile may have mastered this particular power. Darth Bane and Darth Sidious were also notable users of this power; Bane being able to call upon a nearly uncontrollable Force Storm shortly after having been taught the basics of Force Lightning by Githany, who herself had only learnt the power the same day from Qordis.
I am not going to bother verifying the accuracy of this statement or any more of my pieces of evidence as none of the Palpatine-supporters have bothered to verify their evidence which DY repeatedly showed was either inaccurate or taken out of context. While I shall observe this thread and counter blatantly inaccurate statements I have little interest in having clarify every single little detail. Good day, sirs.


As of 3/14/10, TSL is restored. The Sith Lords Restored Content Modification by Stoney and Zbyl has been finished and can be downloaded here.

Lord of Hunger is offline   you may: quote & reply,
Old 08-17-2009, 09:22 PM   #100
Ping
Elementary.
 
Ping's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: Pennsylvania
Posts: 784
Roleplayer 
I seem to remember that Force Storm in KOTOR was just an upgraded lightning. It could be game mechanics. The Force Storm Palpy used is lightning on steroids. You could call it the Force Storm.


"There is no such thing as coincidence, only inevitability" - xxxHoLiC

"Justice? But I don't serve justice, Watson, I serve the truth." - Sherlock Holmes
Ping is offline   you may: quote & reply,
Old 08-18-2009, 04:40 PM   #101
Gob
Rookie
 
Gob's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: Super Awesome Land
Posts: 166
Quote:
Originally Posted by Darth_Yuthura View Post
Or Mace genuinely was killing Palpatine. His Force power may have been intensifying, but his flesh wasn't enduring so well.
Palpatine's face wasn't being melted. It was actually the mask he had created using the Force to hide his corrupted face. When the lightning hit him, the melting of the artificial face damaged his real face even further, causing his inhuman appearance.

Quote:
Correction: Marek beat his ass and would have killed Palpatine if Koto hadn't intervened. Then Palpatine took advantage of his mercy and put him in an unexpected predicament. Had Marek stuck down Palpatine, he would have eliminated the Sith once and for all.
Palpatine was probably holding back because he knew that Marek's potential exceeded his. Even if he wasn't holding back, he didn't even have his lightsaber during the fight. Also, Marek couldn't beat Palpatine in a pure Force fight.

Quote:
Alright, I would accept that. So if you would ask Mr. Lucas that question specifically so he could answer it directly, I will accept his answer. Since he hadn't said that PT were the strongest of all Jedi and all Sith of all time, then it's not canon. And even if it were, why would the next generation of Jedi and Sith be less powerful than the generation before it?
The quote about the PT being the strongest was actually in AotC, during the Geonosis battle. And he was talking about lightsaber combat. The reason for the NJO being weaker than the PT Jedi was because they had to start anew, with a huge amount of knowledge lost.

Quote:
If Palpatine wanted a servant to replace Vader so greatly, then why didn't he just create one instead of investing all those resources into scouring the galaxy for Luke?
This is likely because if he created a new apprentice, he would still have Luke to worry about. If he could track down Luke to kill him, why wouldn't he just make Luke his new apprentice instead?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Lord of Hunger View Post
While I personally don't feel like having to clarify and explain every single aspect of the Star Wars universe in order to continue this debate, I would like to clarify that Palpatine is not the first user of Force Storm or inventor or anything like that:



I am not going to bother verifying the accuracy of this statement or any more of my pieces of evidence as none of the Palpatine-supporters have bothered to verify their evidence which DY repeatedly showed was either inaccurate or taken out of context. While I shall observe this thread and counter blatantly inaccurate statements I have little interest in having clarify every single little detail. Good day, sirs.
That's a different kind of Force storm. You're thinking of the move from KotOR. I'm talking about Palpatine's ability to create wormholes in space that could destroy entire fleets.

Gob is offline   you may: quote & reply,
Old 08-18-2009, 04:56 PM   #102
Lord of Hunger
Hunger, The Lord Of
 
Lord of Hunger's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Korriban, Sith Empire
Posts: 1,022
Current Game: Shogun 2: Total War
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gob
That's a different kind of Force storm. You're thinking of the move from KotOR. I'm talking about Palpatine's ability to create wormholes in space that could destroy entire fleets.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ma Ping
I seem to remember that Force Storm in KOTOR was just an upgraded lightning. It could be game mechanics. The Force Storm Palpy used is lightning on steroids. You could call it the Force Storm.
It's the same ability, Palpy just used it in such a way that it was X10000000000000 bigger and more devastating, yet pointlessly overpowered and uncontrollable. At least Nihilus' apocalypse ability actually had a purpose and some level of control: it gave him energy and prolonged his existence. It was also insidiously more subtle in that it actually targeted people through the Force rather than an easily avoidable physical attack. Palpatine's Force Storm lacked any subtly, could be disrupted by others disrupting his Dark Side connection, could be avoided, and wasted large amounts of energy and caused pointless amounts of destruction. It is likely that the only reason why Palpatine's "Force Storm" is so trumpeted as such a big deal is because of the size. A very good Force ability usually is a smaller effect that causes its damage indirectly and is unnoticeable until it is too late. For a Sith that is supposed to be skilled at deception and manipulation, Palpatine used an ability that was uncharacteristic of his nature and only served to kill him yet again. I believe the term for this is EPIC FAILURE.


As of 3/14/10, TSL is restored. The Sith Lords Restored Content Modification by Stoney and Zbyl has been finished and can be downloaded here.

Lord of Hunger is offline   you may: quote & reply,
Old 08-19-2009, 11:31 AM   #103
RedHawke
Shadow Lord Of The Sith™
 
RedHawke's Avatar
 
Status: Moderator
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Stormreach CA.
Posts: 9,184
Current Game: DDO, Stormreach
*Pokes head in...*

Just an FYI here, but Create Force Storms is not remotely related to Force Lightning or the Lightning Storm in KotOR, and any source stating such is in direct contradiction to the source material for the power, the Dark Empire Comics.

The actual graphics from the comic have it appearing as a cloud-shaped phenomena, so it is also not a worm-hole or other such nonsense.

Again just FYI.


"Beware the form-fitting black armor-clad Drow hottie with twin Mineral II Greensteel Khopeshes!"
"Liella d'Orien says, '"You're the fool, Devil. -- Witness the power of this fully ARMED and OPERATIONAL Titan!"'"
----------------------------------------------------------------------
RedHawke is offline   you may: quote & reply,
Old 08-24-2009, 03:56 PM   #104
TKA-001
I sneer at thee.
 
TKA-001's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2005
Posts: 1,535
Forum Veteran 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Darth_Yuthura
Kreia.
No, I'm pretty sure that her use of Force Drain on the Jedi Masters wasn't really a fight. Sort of like how a gunman going up to somebody and shooting him isn't really a fight. But if you pay extremely close attention to the confrontation at the game's end,
spoiler:
you will find that Kreia does indeed use a lightsaber to fight you.


Quote:
Originally Posted by Darth_Yuthura
As Skywalker wasn't even expected to be there when the fight broke out, Palpatine had no motive to let himself be defeated.
Like Palpatine couldn't sense Anakin's approach and had no idea what he was going to do once he was disarmed... What do you think he means when he talks about Forseeing things all the time?

Quote:
Then he did it [redirect the lightning] without a saber in the cutscene. The only reason that he died was because his intent wasn't to beat Palpatine, but to keep the senators from being killed.
Wrong. The apprentice did no redirection of any sort when Palpatine stopped playing dead. The Emperor spammed him with lightning and he just took it until it was over. The cutscene does not show him blasting any back at him, only standing in front of it with his arms out in front of him. The game implies and the novel confirms that the lightning was putting him under enough pain to make him want to pass out, so he clearly was not absorbing it anywhere close to the level that Yoda, Dooku, or Sidious could do it, if he was at all. The novel makes no mention of him actually using the Force to absorb it, so it's likely that he was just standing in the energy's path. And the energy explosion that happens when the apprentice dies isn't really his doing, because it's more or less of the same nature as the energy bursts which Palpatine and the Jedi in TFU died.

Quote:
There also was a lot of reason to assume he was in danger from Starkiller. Before Kota stopped him, the Emperor was just one lightsaber stroke away from death. The Emperor was beaten by a better opponent.
Again, like Palpatine couldn't have just continued to defend himself with lightning.

Quote:
Again the use of the word 'obvious.' I could just as easily say that Palpatine obviously wasn't able to beat Windu, which was why he would have died if Anakin didn't attack Mace.
I say it is obvious because it is obvious if you bother to actually use your brain by taking Palpatine's personality, style of doing things, the implications made by the course of events, the fact that Palpatine was disarmed immediately before Anakin entered the room, and the fact that Palpatine was used to seeing the future into account, it actually might make a lick of sense. The same applies to the scene with the Emperor and Vader's apprentice.

Quote:
Starkiller beat the Emperor and nearly executed him,
Force pushing someone a few times (game) and throwing some debris at him (novel) a defeat does not make.

Quote:
and very well could have disposed of him. Killing him would have been the more favorable way out, but that was lost when Palpatine went for Kota and the Senators.
Quote:
but that stupid Kota interfered.
(Tangent) If there is any one thing that I truly detest about your style of argument (other than your tendency to pull "facts" out of thin air), it's your habit of throwing insults at your favorite bash characters at every single opportunity, instead of focusing your energy on making sense.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Lord of Hunger
It's the same ability,
Just LOOK at it.




You're telling me that the former is just a bigger version of the latter. That's crazy. Downright freaking crazy. I don't see a single bolt of lightning in the first picture.

A Force storm is not a really big Force lightning bananza. It's a hyperspace wormhole which is directed by the user, which has two known functions: The most obvious one is the destruction of fleets of starships, and the second appears to be teleportation. The Emperor uses a Force storm to transport Luke Skywalker from the surface of Coruscant to an Imperial Dungeon ship in Dark Empire I. So the Force Storm does have more than one use.

EDIT: I initially thought that you simply didn't know/had forgotten what the Dark Empire Force storms are, but looking back back at your post, I saw that you had actually quoted Gob's post, which correctly stated that Palpatine's Force storms were not related to the lightning power, and simply flat-out denied it instead of explaining how it might have been in error.

Quote:
At least Nihilus' apocalypse ability actually had a purpose and some level of control: it gave him energy and prolonged his existence.
Yeah, I'm sure living like Nihilus is something to be envied.

Quote:
It was also insidiously more subtle in that it actually targeted people through the Force rather than an easily avoidable physical attack.
How is any weapon or technique which obliterates all life on a planet subtle? And may I ask how it is easy to avoid something of sufficient size and speed to destroy a fleet of starships?

Quote:
Palpatine's Force Storm lacked any subtly
So what? It's not supposed to be subtle. It's supposed to blow **** up. Criticizing a weapon that's supposed to blow **** up for not being subtle makes about as much sense as criticizing stormtroopers for shooting people - It's what they're ****ing supposed to do.

Quote:
could be disrupted by others disrupting his Dark Side connection
"It has a weakness, much like everything else in existence, and therefore it sucks and is basically useless."

Quote:
and wasted large amounts of energy
Evidence that it wastes large amounts of energy?

Quote:
and caused pointless amounts of destruction.
That's sort of what a weapon of mass destruction is for, you know... And since when is destroying an enemy fleet pointless? It could be used to wipe out a hostile group of ships without risking a single ship of your own.

Quote:
It is likely that the only reason why Palpatine's "Force Storm" is so trumpeted as such a big deal is because of the size. A very good Force ability usually is a smaller effect that causes its damage indirectly and is unnoticeable until it is too late.
So there is a much smaller Force power which could also destroy a fleet in minutes? I wonder what this is and why I've never heard of it before.


"There is something going on in time and space, and beyond time and space, which, whether we like it or not, spells duty." -Winston Churchill

"For of all sad words of tongue or pen, The saddest are these: 'It might have been!'" -John Whittier

"Apathy is death." -Kreia

Last edited by TKA-001; 08-24-2009 at 04:44 PM.
TKA-001 is offline   you may: quote & reply,
Old 09-12-2009, 10:59 PM   #105
Jkmc
Lurker
 
Join Date: Aug 2009
Posts: 5
To bring this back on topic, Team 1 would win. How? Kreia would simply prattle on and on... and on... and on... and on... until all the other teams committed suicide by sticking their swords or sabers in themselves.
Jkmc is offline   you may: quote & reply,
Old 11-03-2009, 10:22 AM   #106
Visas
Rookie
 
Visas's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: The Ravager
Posts: 71
Team 2 for me.
Visas is offline   you may: quote & reply,
Old 11-03-2009, 11:21 AM   #107
SirBoomstick91
Lurker
 
SirBoomstick91's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 8
Umm... Team 2? Maybe out of favouritism, maybe it isn't but I voted for team 2.

SirBoomstick91 is offline   you may: quote & reply,
Post a new thread. Add a reply to this thread. Indicate all threads in this forum as read. Subscribe to this forum. RSS feed: this forum RSS feed: all forums
Go Back   LucasForums > Network > Knights of the Old Republic > Game Discussion > Telos Tourist Bureau > Dark Side Battle Royal

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 05:05 PM.

LFNetwork, LLC ©2002-2011 - All rights reserved.
Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.